Strictly Dishonorable (1951 film)

Strictly Dishonorable is a 1951 romantic comedy film written, produced, and directed by Melvin Frank and Norman Panama, starring Ezio Pinza and Janet Leigh. It is the second film adaptation of Preston Sturges' 1929 hit Broadway play of the same name, following a pre-Code version released by Universal Pictures in 1931 under the same title.

Set in 1920s New York, the story follows amorous opera star Augustino "Gus" Caraffa (Ezio Pinza) who encounters Isabelle Perry (Janet Leigh), a naive music student from Mississippi and one of his most devoted admirers. When a newspaper photographer captures them in a compromising kiss, a marriage of convenience is proposed to avoid scandal. Isabelle, secretly in love with Gus, agrees to the arrangement—hoping that he will eventually return her feelings.^[2][3]

• Ezio Pinza as Count Augustino "Gus" Caraffa
• Janet Leigh as Isabelle Perry
• Millard Mitchell as Bill Dempsey
• Gale Robbins as Marie Donnelly
• Maria Palmer as Countess Lili Szadvany
• Esther Minciotti as Mme. Maria Caraffa
• Silvio Minciotti as Uncle Nito
• Arthur Franz as Henry Greene
• Sandro Giglio as Tomasso
• Hugh Sanders as Harry Donnelly
• Mario Siletti as Luigi

• Opera and Broadway star Pinza had previously appeared in the film Mr. Imperium which was shot before Strictly Dishonorable, but Strictly Dishonorable was released first, so that film marked his dramatic acting debut. Pinza went on to make only one more film, Tonight We Sing (1953) for Twentieth Century-Fox, with Roberta Peters and Isaac Stern.^[4][5][6]
• Greta Garbo, John Gilbert and Lewis Stone among others, appear in archival footage from the MGM silent film A Woman of Affairs (1928). Stone played the part of "Judge Dempsey" in the 1931 version of Strictly Dishonorable.^[7]
• The operatic scenes were staged by Vladimir Rosing.
• "Dempsey" was the maiden name of Preston Sturges' mother.
• The prolific comic character actress Kathleen Freeman appears uncredited as a movie theatre organist.
• Scott R. Beal, who appears uncredited in the bit part of a vendor, was primarily an assistant director. He received an Academy Award as "Best Assistant Director" in 1934 and was nominated again in 1935.^[8]

• "I'll See You in My Dreams" - by Isham Jones (music) and Gus Kahn (lyrics)
• "Everything I Have Is Yours" - by Burton Lane (music) and Harold Adamson (lyrics)
• "La veau d'or" from the opera Faust - by Charles Gounod (music) and Jules Barbier and Michel Carré (libretto)
• "Se a caso madama" from the opera Le nozze di Figaro - by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (music) and Lorenzo da Ponte (libretto)
• Unnamed aria from the opera Il ritorno di Césare - by Mario Castelnuovo-Tedesco (music and lyrics)^[9]

Notes:

• Il ritorno di Césare is a fictitious opera created by Mario Castelnuovo-Tedesco for the film, and staged by Vladimir Rosing.^[4]

Preston Sturges approached Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer with the idea of doing a remake of Strictly Dishonorable with Ezio Pinza, and received $60,000 for the rights, but was disappointed when he was not hired to write the screenplay.^[4]

Strictly Dishonorable was in production from mid-January to mid-March 1951^[10] and was released on July 3 of that year.^[11]

According to MGM records the film earned $660,000 in the US and Canada and $221,000 elsewhere, resulting in a loss of $664,000.^[1]

Lux Radio Theatre broadcast a radio adaptation of the film on December 8, 1952, with Janet Leigh reprising her role and Fernando Lamas replacing Pinza.^[4][12]

• ​Strictly Dishonorable​ at the Internet Broadway Database
• Strictly Dishonorable at IMDb
• Strictly Dishonorable at the TCM Movie Database
• Strictly Dishonorable at the AFI Catalog of Feature Films
• Strictly Dishonorable at Rotten Tomatoes