Enver Pasha's campaign in Bukhara
| Enver Pasha's campaign in Bukhara | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Part of the Basmachi movement and Enver Pasha's Rebellion | |||||||||
Enver Pasha's influence in Central Asia (shaded areas on map) | |||||||||
| |||||||||
| Belligerents | |||||||||
|
Basmachi movement Military support: Afghanistan |
Russian SFSR Bukharan PSR Khorezm PSR | ||||||||
| Commanders and leaders | |||||||||
|
Enver Pasha (WIA) Molla Abdulkahhar Devletmend Beg Ibrahim Bek[1] Faizal Maksum Turdu Toksab Hurram Bek Junaid Khan Abdulkhai Arifov Korşirmat |
Leon Trotsky Mikhail Frunze Semyon Budyonny Sergey Kamenev Jēkabs Peterss M. Marosin † Fayzulla Xoʻjayev N. Kakurin P. Pavlov Georges Agabekov | ||||||||
| Strength | |||||||||
| 7,000–26,000 | 100,000–200,000 (reserves); over 20,000 in combat | ||||||||
| Casualties and losses | |||||||||
| See § Casualties | See § Casualties | ||||||||
In January 1922, the Basmachi movement under the command of Turkish general Enver Pasha launched a military campaign to wrest control of Bukhara and Khorezm from Soviet forces led by Mikhail Frunze, Semyon Budyonny and Kamenev.[2] The Basmachis seized most of the Bukharan and Khorezm People's Soviet Republics, challenging Soviet authority in the region by May, but Soviet counter-offensives in June forced the Basmachis to end their operation. The campaign formed part of the broader Basmachi Movement against Soviet rule in Central Asia following the Russian Civil War.
Background
Turkish general Enver Pasha was sent to Bukhara by Moscow in the autumn of 1921 and arrived on 8 November 1921.[3][4] Instead of focusing solely on Soviet objectives, he became involved with the Emir of Afghanistan, Amanullah. With ambitions to lead a Central Asian confederation, Amanullah stationed his most capable commanders along the northern frontier and, without formally committing, began corresponding with Enver.[5]
By 1922, Soviet forces combined military, political, and economic measures, cutting off towns from the countryside. While food continued to reach urban centers, the Basmachis and rural populations suffered from famine, weakening the movement's local support.[6]
During Enver Pasha's insurgency in Turkestan, Soviet forces deployed approximately 100,000 troops under Mikhail Frunze to confront his forces.[7] Some estimates place the force between 100,000 and 160,000,[8] or even 200,000.[9] The units were primarily cavalry, but the force was also well-equipped with artillery, armored cars, and aircraft.[10]
Enver Pasha's campaign
January–February offensives
At the end of January 1922, Enver Pasha led about 200 Basmachi fighters in a successful siege of Dushanbe. During the battles of 20–22 January, Enver inflicted heavy casualties on the Russian forces.[11][12]
The town was besieged on 28 January or 8 February. The Russians sent wireless messages requesting reinforcements from the garrisons in Tashkent, Bukhara, and Samarkand.[13][14] Meanwhile, a Russian cavalry detachment dispatched from Denov to relieve the Bolsheviks trapped in Dushanbe was ambushed; its soldiers were neutralized, and machine guns, rifles, and ammunition were captured.[15]
On 31 January, Soviet troops attempted to raid the village of Kampçı but ultimately failed. The Basmachis captured one horse, inflicted heavy losses on the Russians, and pursued them all the way to Dushanbe.[16]
On 7 February, the Soviets suffered over 100 casualties. The Basmachis captured a machine gun, along with numerous rifles and ammunition. Seventy-two Russian troops defected and joined the Basmachis[12]
According to Cemal Kutay, the Russian commander in Dushanbe, Mazarof, reported that Enver Pasha had organized a strong resistance movement with growing local support, inflicting heavy losses on Russian forces and compelling them to contemplate abandoning the city.[11][12]
By 14 February, during a smoky and snowy noon, the town was completely captured, and Enver pursued the retreating Russian forces toward Mirtyube. His troops seized 120 rifles and two machine guns, inflicting around 100 casualties on the Russian garrison, while 88 soldiers defected to his side.[17][18][19] At Mirtyube, Enver's forces clashed with the Bolsheviks once again, resulting in a decisive victory for Enver's troops.[20][21] The remaining elements of the 7th Soviet Regiment retreated to Boysun.[22]
Between 28 January and 22 February, Enver Pasha's forces, numbering around 1,500 men, captured Sariosiyo, Qubodiyon, Yurchi, and Denov against a Soviet force estimated at 7,000–8,000 troops. During these engagements, the Russians suffered around seventy deaths, abandoning their supplies, ammunition, five machine guns, two cannons, and hundreds of rifles. Enver was wounded during the operations, and several Russian soldiers defected to join the Basmachi forces.[23][24][25]
These victories increased Enver's reputation across Central Asia and enhanced his prestige in the Islamic world.[26][27] In February, Enver was warned of an impending Russian counterattack and withdrew to Kofarnihon.[18]
Uprisings in Dagestan and Chechnya
Enver's successful gains in Bukhara began to spread to Dagestan and Chechnya, where signs of unrest had already emerged.[28][29][30] In response to the armed detachments of N. Gotsinsky, the Soviet authorities established the Republican Military Council for Combating Banditry in Dagestan on January 30, 1922. By August 1922, the situation had escalated to the point that Dagestan was placed under martial law.[31][32]
In early 1922, Soviet authorities warned that the situation in Dagestan was critical. A telegram from March 1922 described a surge in "banditism," growing anti-Soviet agitation led by mullahs and "Turkish emissaries," and feared that the uprising was spreading into Dagestan.[33]
In the same year, Gotsinsky's associates sought international recognition from the League of Nations for a future independent Caucasian state, citing solidarity with broader Muslim resistance movements.[32]
March–April offensives
According to the ninth page of a report by Galib Pasha, the cities of Bukhara, Qarshi, Karmana, and Chardzhou were under Soviet control, while the remaining territories of the Emirate were held by Enver Pasha's forces in spring. The other provinces of Bukhara were listed as Shahrisabz, Sherobod, and, in Eastern Bukhara, the cities of Termez, Dushanbe, Hisar, and Gharm.[34]
In early spring or January, the Basmachis occupied the Karshi, Shahrisabz, and G'uzor regions, opening the roads to Western Bukhara. Around the same time, Abdulkhai Arifov, the military commissioner of the Bukhara Republic, who commanded a full Bukhara cavalry squadron of 300 men, defected to the Basmachi side.[35][36]
According to the Commander-in-Chief of the British forces in India, reporting to the War Office on 10 May 1922, unrest broke out in Askabad region in March, in which the Zaloni bazaar was looted. Troops were dispatched but later withdrawn once order was restored.[36] Meanwhile, Termez remained under rebel siege, and the Bolsheviks sent reinforcements from Kerki.[36]
Koyenikov, the official Soviet Russian representative in Bukhara, reported to the People's Commissariat for Foreign Affairs that "the Basmachis were growing stronger and becoming organized in Eastern Bukhara, were also active in Western Bukhara, and that even the capital, Bukhara itself, was in danger."[37]
On 25 March, fighting erupted at Qarsang, where Enver Pasha's forces killed roughly 245 Russian troops and seized three machine guns. The next day, Enver reported that his men were facing around 5,000 Russian soldiers while having only about 500 rifles at their disposal. In the village of Tal, east of Boysun, Russian units—about 400 men backed by two artillery pieces and four machine guns—launched repeated attacks on Enver's outposts over three days. They were repelled each time, leaving roughly 80 dead before retreating. These victories secured Enver Pasha full control over Kulob, Darvaz, Karategin, Baljuvon, and Qurghonteppa.[38]
In a 26 March 1922 letter from Mazar-i-Sharif, Ali Nazif Bey reported to Enver Pasha that Bukhara's diplomatic envoys were seeking Afghan support while Russian troop numbers in the region were being under- and over-reported; he warned that local anti-Soviet forces under leaders such as Danyal and Jabbar were growing, that Turkmen detachments were preparing to move, and that efforts were underway to sabotage the railway lines through Merv and Chardzhou. The letter indicates Nazif's expectation of imminent operations and his reliance on orders from Kabul.[39]
Due to these successes, on 28 March 1922, Enver Pasha was declared commander of all forces in Eastern Bukhara by a decree from Amir Alim Khan.[40][41]
A. Nagornov, the Consul General in Bukhara, sent a report on 2 April 1922 describing the loss of Soviet control in Eastern Bukhara, and the negative effect and will probably have an even greater impact on the country's food resources in the near future.[42] At that time, around 3,000 Basmachi cavalry laid siege to Kerki and eventually captured the town, inflicting heavy casualties on the Soviet forces.[43][44]
On 13 April 1922, Ruz Muhammed Bek and a unit of Basmachis arrived at Enver Pasha's headquarters, bringing him a horse, a bird, a chest, and a letter from Korşirmat.[45]
On 20 April 1922, Joseph Stalin, then serving as Secretary of the Central Committee, sent a classified telegram to Sergo Ordzhonikidze instructing him to travel from Tiflis to Tashkent to assess the situation on the Turkestan Front. Stalin ordered an immediate investigation into the Basmachi uprising in Fergana and Bukhara, directing Ordzhonikidze to determine whether native units were supplying insurgents with arms, whether local authorities were obstructing military operations, and whether the composition of the Turkfront, Turkburo, or Turkestan Commission required reorganization. The telegram also mandated the introduction of martial law in Bukhara and Turkestan and requested detailed recommendations on measures to suppress the revolt and restore control.[46] Ordzhonikidze was also given the task of ascertaining "how great is the danger of [losing] Bukhara and Ferghana."[47]
The Soviet forces suffered heavy casualties and severe attrition from disease, exhaustion, and the harsh climate while combating the Basmachi insurgents. Shortages of food, water, and medical supplies, compounded by continuous attacks from the Basmachi, left the troops in a critical condition. In a report to the Turkestan Front headquarters, the commander Vladimir Martynovsky stated:[48]
"Diseases and exhaustion disabled 80% of personnel. Dozens of Red Army soldiers were killed or wounded. Breaking out from the dense encirclement is practically impossible."
Fergana Valley campaign
In mid-March, Basmachis besieged and on the same day, captured Margilan, while heavy fighting occurred in the Kokand region, damaging nearby oil wells. Approximately 2,500 Bolshevik soldiers deserted—taking four machine guns with them—and joined the insurgents. In Tashkent, the 14th Uzbek Regiment also defected en masse, bringing weapons and ammunition.[49] The railway north of Tashkent was repeatedly cut as the Basmachi movement spread further across the region. Bolshevik reinforcements were dispatched to Kerki, while a growing number of deserters fled into Persia.[50][36]
According to military commissar Urastemov, Basmachi forces took Uchqoʻrgʻon and eventually Namangan in March. They killed 51 communists during the operation and captured another 75 as prisoners.[51]
In spring 1922, Leon Trotsky personally took charge of operations against the Basmachis and traveled to Fergana.The Basmachis then engaged in brutal combat; after liberating villages, they executed all Soviet officials, especially commissars.[52][53]
In mid-1922, a Revolutionary Committee report from Fergana warned that the city was forced to organize civil defense measures in response to unexpectedly strong Basmachi attacks in the area.[54]
May offensives
In May 1922, after receiving military aid from Afghanistan—including 800 soldiers, 100 British rifles, and 80 camel-loads of ammunition.[55][56][57][58] Enver Pasha mobilized from his headquarters in the Kafirun region with approximately 3,000 to 20,000 Basmachi fighters under his command.[note 1]
On 11 May, the Basmachis attacked the city of Karmana. After heavy fighting, however, they were forced to withdraw.[59] The following day, G. K. Ordzhonikidze arrived in Bukhara from Tashkent and sharply criticized the hesitant policies of the Bukharan satellite government.[60] Soviet envoy Shalva Eliava reported to Joseph Stalin that Eastern Bukhara was effectively in open revolt under Enver Pasha's leadership and urged that Enver's elimination was essential to restoring control.[61]
On 13 May, Enver launched a broad offensive, taking Saraykemer and most of the city of Boysun under his possession.[62][25] In 1922, multiple reports described Enver's growing power in Bukhara. A detailed report submitted to Galip Pasha, appointed as the Ottoman representative to Bukhara, confirmed that more than half of the territory of the Emirate of Bukhara was under Enver's military control, rather than Soviet authority.[63]
At 23:00 on 14 May, Stalin warned Ordzhonikidze in Tashkent about Enver's operatives and leftist elements in a coded telegram. Along with criticizing Eliava's assessment of Bukhara, Stalin stressed the need for combining military occupation with political concessions, particularly regarding the return of waqf lands, and urged measures against disruptive factions.[64]
Enver's reforms
During this period, the Basmachi movement also became more centralized; regular meetings were held among the leaders of Khiva, Bukhara, and Fergana.[65][66] He established a unified army in Bukhara, implemented a Western-style chain of command, and incorporated Turkish officers into his ranks.[67][66][68] He also set up cartridge and ammunition factories and maintained regular contact with Afghanistan.[66][69]
Enver also decided to unify his forces under a single uniform. He informed Hacı Sami in Afghanistan, and through Amanullah Khan's foster brother Ahmet Khan, he received khaki uniforms and lambskin hats made from Karagöl pelts. Because boots were scarce, local craftsmen produced light, upturned shoes modeled after Anatolian footwear.[70][71]
Foreign reports
On 29 May, Colonel Humphrys—the British diplomatic representative in Kabul—reported to Lord Curzon that Enver Pasha had recently inflicted a heavy defeat on General Budyonny, who commanded about 50,000 men. Newspapers in Istanbul were circulating the same claim around the same time.[72][73]
According to The New York Herald report of July 29, by the end of May Enver Pasha had launched offensives from Bukhara toward Tashkent, Kokand, Khujand, and Naryn. As a result, he held a line extending from Tashkent to Khujand and eastward through Kokand to Naryn, threatening both Tashkent and the Krasnovodsk railway.[74][75]
A report published by The New York Times on 31 July 1922 stated that Enver Pasha had occupied a region roughly comparable in size to the state of Texas.[76]
According to Current History journal and New York Herald, Enver Pasha also captured Yarkand and Kashgar alongside Bukhara and Samarkand.[74][75]
Aftermath
During this campaign, sown areas in Bukhara were reduced by 72 percent, and livestock numbers fell by two-thirds.[77] By early 1922, Enver had already seized much of the Bukharan People's Soviet Republic and attracted several Jadid reformers, former collaborators of the Soviet regime, to his cause.[78]
Later that month, Basmachi strength around Samarkand was such that when Eliava and Ordzhonikidze could visit Ulug Bek's Observatory only under heavy guard.[79] When Enver's forces controlled the entire eastern part of Bukhara, the Soviet officials viewed the situation as politically more dangerous than the military successes achieved by Enver.[80][81]
Bolshevik response
The Bukharan Army could no longer contain the movement, and fearing the collapse of their government, the Chairman of the Council of People's Nazirs of the Bukharan PSR, Fayzulla Xo'jayev, approved a further increase in Soviet troop deployment in the area.[82]
In response to Fayzulla Xoʻjayev's request, the Bukhara Group of Troops was formed, drawing units from the Moscow Military District and Belarus, and totaling 4,500 rifles, 3,030 sabers, and 20 artillery pieces[83][84]
On 20 April, 20,000 troops from Samarkand and Chardzhou were directed toward Kogon, on the Kizilsu–Tashkent railway, 8,000 of whom were sent to Qarshi.[59]
For the direct command of military operations in the region, RKKA commander S.S. Kamenev and Chekist Ya.Kh. Peters were sent to purge the Bukharan party, military, and militia of Pan-Turkist and Pan-Islamist elements.[85]
Under the Turkestan Front, commanded by N. Kakurin and P. Pavlov, Soviet authorities organized two Cavalry Brigades, two cavalry squadrons, and one rifle division, comprising roughly 7,500–8,000 soldiers with 20 machine guns.[85] Peters, a veteran Russian revolutionary and one of the first commanders of the Communist Party, along with Kamenev, oversaw operations against Enver in Bukhara.[60][85] A squadron of four aircraft—two Nieuport fighters and two 1½-Strutters—was deployed to southern Bukhara to provide air support against Basmachis.[86] The Soviets also purchased about 24 LVG VI reconnaissance planes from Germany, the majority of which were sent to the Central Asian front.[87]
First peace attempts
As a last resort, the Soviet government summoned Fayzulla Xoʻjayev, the highly trusted head of the Bukharan Government, to Moscow, and through him, they offered a truce to Enver Pasha.[79][88][89] The Soviets, through an eleven-member delegation sent from Kazan, proposed granting Enver Pasha broad concessions in nearly all matters and urged him to reach an agreement. In response, Enver convened the National Pact Congress.[90] However, Enver's reply was uncompromising:[79]
"Peace is only acceptable after the withdrawal of Russian troops from Turkestan soil."
As a result of the negotiations, the Soviet offer was rejected, even though Togan urged Enver to accept the peace as he had received news from Moscow that the Soviet government intended to send 100,000 additional troops to Turkestan if they refused.[79] The National Pact of Congress consequently issued a decision for full independence.[91] Enver himself remained optimistic; hoping for better days, the headquarters was later moved from Pulluhakiyan to Kafirun.
Second peace attempts
Around the same time, through Nariman Narimanov, Council of Azerbaijan SSR, Enver Pasha sent an ultimatum to Moscow, demanding the withdrawal of Soviet troops from Turkestan. On 30 March 1922, the Soviet administration established a new front in Bukhara against the Basmachi, along with a special operations staff. Special brigades were organized in Samarkand and sent to Bukhara.[92]
Meanwhile, Enver continued to pursue his objectives. On 18 May 1922, the Central Committee discussed the "Turkestan–Bukhara issue" and issued a decree initiating a broad political campaign against him, while also dispatching military reinforcements to the Bukharan People's Soviet Republic.[84][93]
On 19 May 1922, Enver sent a ultimatum to the Soviet government, again demanding that the Red Army withdraw from Turkestan,Bukhara, and Khiva within 14–15 days. The demand was rejected by the Soviet authorities.[94]
As a response to the ultimatum, the Soviet government issued a brief declaration: "Enver Pasha is an agent of British imperialism."[95][96][97]
Following this, the Soviet government reinforced its forces in the region and established an extensive espionage network, which was placed under the direct leadership of Georges Agabekov.[95]
Molla Abdulkahhar's campaign
Background
In Western Bukhara, the Basmachi movement was also gaining strength, and by late 1921, all the provinces of the region were administered by Abdulkahhar and Faizul Makhdum.[98][99] Their growing influence increased local recruitment and drew more volunteers into joining the Basmachis. During this period, Abdulkahhar established communication with Amir Alim Khan in Afghanistan, Lakay Ibrahim, and Enver Pasha in Bukhara. According to Amir Alim Khan, Abdulkahhar's army was reinforced by 6,000 men around Bukhara, 2,000 from Vabkent, 2,000 from Qiziltepa, 2,000 from Shofirkon, 2,500 from Romitan and Peshku, and 2,000 from Kogon district.[100][101] Bolshevik strength in Bukhara was estimated at 20,000 troops.[102]
Bukhara offensive
Following his operations toward Bukhara,[26][103] Abdulkahhar captured the districts of Gijduvon, Shofirkon, Vabkent, Romitan, and Nurata. In March 1922, he launched a major offensive against Bukhara, seizing most of the city and advancing toward Kogon, a key railway junction about 12.8 km (12 versts) from old Bukhara.[104][105][101] Abdulkahhar also seized the Baha' al-Din Naqshband shrine, the resting place of the founder of the Naqshbandi Sufi Order.[106] The Red Army suffered defeat near the Mehta Qasim Bridge over the Zarafshan River.[107] To protect their supply lines to Bukhara, the Soviet command dispatched cavalry from Samarkand, Budyonny's forces from the Trans-Caspian front, and additional troops from Tashkent, the Fergana Valley, and Central Turkestan.[108] In total, the Soviets sent about 12,000 additional troops and several armored trains to Bukhara.[109][110] Overall, the campaign inflicted heavy casualties on the Bolsheviks and resulted in the Basmachis seizing Bukhara.[111][112][113]
Junaid Khan's campaign
Background
In November 1921, Junaid Khan signed a peace agreement with the Khorezm Republic, while waiting for an opportune moment to seize control of Khorezm.[114] He commanded about 15,000 men in 1922,[115][116] although this figure is disputed, as contemporary estimates vary.[117] In early months of 1922 during the height of the Basmachi movement, Enver Pasha sent convoys and letters to Junaid Khan who was offering resistance to the Bolsheviks in the Karakum desert.[118][119] Several Turkmen tribes also joined Junaid Khan, who also held the title of "Commander of the Army of Islam" alongside Enver Pasha.[115][120] As a result, the territory under Khivan Basmachi control expanded significantly.[118]
Khiva offensive
In April 1922, Junaid Khan captured the Boldumsaz District.[121] On April 12, he attacked the Chovdur tribes, who were allied with Soviets, inflicting heavy casualties.[122]
In 1922, Basmachi uprisings broke out against the Soviet government in Khiva, where the Soviets suffered a heavy defeat against Junaid Khan and Abdulkahhar in Khiva.[123][29][124] This enabled Junaid Khan to seize control of Khorezm.[125] However, due to increase of Soviet dispatch in the area, a portion of his troops began negotiations with the Red Army, and about 150 Basmachis eventually surrendered.[126]
Congress of Kafirun
On 9 April, Enver circulated a nine-point directive to Basmachi units calling for internal unity, strict discipline, and coordinated operations: he asked fighters to settle local disputes, unite under a single banner, cut Soviet supply lines through raids, build effective intelligence networks, and send delegations to the congress planned after 10 April. [127]
While touring the southern front of Boysun, Enver and his men passed through the village of Kafirun, located about 2 km away.[128] On 15 April 1922, an enormous crowd gathered under the command of their headquarters. For the council scheduled that day, nearly one hundred Basmachis from across Turkestan assembled, accompanied by approximately 3,000 armed fighters united under the Enver Pasha's banner for a common ideal.[129]
Precisely at eight o'clock, Enver Pasha—accompanied by Chief of Staff Hasan Bey, Afghan Captain Afzaleddin, and Afghan volunteers under the command of Ahmet Khan—stood before the assembled commanders to address them in Ottoman Turkish:[130]
"«ای ترکستانِ مُجاهدلَرِنین قهرمانلاری! سیزلَر بو گؤزل و مُثِلْسِز وطنِیْنینیزی، یِت(?) ییل دیر آنونُ مُردَر چِیزمَهلَری ایله قَدیْمَلییان روسلاردان آزاد ائتمک اُچون بورادا توپلانمیش سیز. قدَرین چِلْوَسی ایله بیز، باشقا بیر مملکتده دوغولوب بِیوُمُوش افغان گؤنُلُلوَر ایله تقدیرینیزده شریک اولوروز.
بِن و ضابطانیم حُضورونوزدا واعده ائدیریم کی، بو مقدّراتا شریک اولماغدان پِشیمانلیق حسِی اِتمِیرم. سون نفَسیمَغَه قَدَر بو دَوا اوچون چالیشاجام. اینجا وردیغیم یَمینی شَرَفْینِیز ایله تَصْدِیق ائدِمَنِیزی طلب ائدیرم.»"
English Translation:
"O heroes of Turkestan's mujahideen, you have gathered here to liberate your beautiful and unparalleled homeland from the Russians, who for seventy years have trampled it under their filthy boots. By the twists of fate, we, born in another land, and the Afghan volunteers share in your destiny. On behalf of myself and my fellow officers, I promise before you that I do not regret sharing in your fate. I will work for this cause until my last breath. I ask that you, in turn, endorse the pledge I make here with your honor."
In response, all the Basmachis affirmed the Kafirun decisions, declaring: "We pledge on our honor!"[131]
Decisions of the Congress and creation of The Turkestan Provisional Government
Following the congress, the Turkestan Provisional Government was established, outlining a comprehensive military and administrative framework for territories of Eastern Bukhara cleared of Soviet control. The resolutions called for the formation of regular forces under provincial commanders (leshkerbashis), the mobilization of new uprisings in remaining regions, and the creation of local governments in liberated areas. Funding was to be secured through zakat, tributes, or additional taxes based on wealth, managed by appointed collectors. The decrees regulated logistics, reporting, and inter-provincial coordination, ordering daily communication with central command and mutual military assistance during emergencies. They also instructed forces to sabotage Soviet infrastructure, suppress espionage, and treat prisoners humanely. Ultimate authority over all political and military operations was vested in Enver Pasha.[132][133]
In accordance with the decisions made at the Congress of Kafirun on 15 April 1922, Enver Pasha established local and civil administrations in the liberated areas and stationed a portion of his troops in the mentioned locations to maintain control and security.[134][135][136] The same congress also proclaimed the Turkestan Provisional Government, headquartered in Samarkand.[137] They declared a constitution consisting of 7 sections and 36 articles.[138][139] Osman hoca was appointed President of Bukhara, while Shir Muhammad Bek, commander-in-chief of the Islamic Armies, was elected as the president.[66][89][140] Abdul hamid as named minister of War, and Ali Riza served as Deputy Minister of War.[141][142] The new state was founded on the principles of private property and governance under Shari'a law.[66]
The government established by Shir Muhammad Bek relocated its center five times within three months, moving successively between Samarkand, Namangan, Osh, Margilan, and Naryn.[143][144] The Kafirun Congress, attended by representatives including Cora Hoca from Kabul, resolved to organize regular military units in liberated areas of Eastern Bukhara, prepare local populations for combat, appoint commanders to lead revolutionary actions in each region, and levy taxes if resources were insufficient.[123]
The congress consisted of sixteen resolutions, the last of which granted Enver Pasha full authority over all military and political affairs. He was formally presented with a seal inscribed:[123] "Damad-ı Halifet'ül Müslimin, Emir-i Leşker-i İslâm Seyyid Enver" ("Son-in-law of the Caliph of the Muslims, Commander of the Islamic Army, Seyyid Enver") symbolizing his authority and consolidating the support of the national movement's command.[145][133]
Casualties
Soviet losses in the Basmachi conflict varied widely according to different sources. Total Soviet casualties were reported at around 17,000 in Termez and Kerki alone,[44] some sources estimate as many as 259,000 between 1921 and 1922, though Fraser considers these figures "highly suspect".[146][147] Vladimir Martynovsky reported that losses have reached up to 80% of Soviet forces in the region.[148] According to Grigori F. Krivosheev, from January 1921 to July 1922 Soviet casualties totaled 1,793.[149]
According to a Revolutionary Committee report covering January–July 1922, the Basmachi in the Namangan region killed 17 militia and likely a large number of civilians, though exact figures were unknown due to disrupted communications. Since March, fifteen militia deserted to join the Basmachi, bringing 21 rifles and several hundred rounds of ammunition, while the authorities noted they could not measure how much of the population was suffering from Basmachi activity, only that it was “great.” The Basmachi also captured civilians, robbed villages, and seized weapons during skirmishes.[150]
Total Basmachi casualties were reported at approximately 4,000 according to the Krugosvet encyclopedia.[151] A Soviet report indicated that only 100–150 fighters remained under the main Western Bukhara emirs by autumn 1922, down from roughly 1,000 following heavy fighting.[152] Another Soviet report estimated that Basmachi strength declined from 26,000 fighters in May 1922 to 6,700 by October 1922.[153] According to Baymirza Hayit, Turkestani casualties had reached approximately 700,000 by the end of 1923.[147]
Result
A report from the chairman of the commission, dated August 7, Sokolnikov, acknowledged that after four years of struggle, the Bolsheviks had failed to eliminate the Basmachi. Instead, the insurgency had expanded across Samarkand, parts of Syr-Darya, and Turkmen oblasts—becoming a widespread regional revolt and a major embarrassment for Soviet authority in Turkestan.[154][155]
As a result of Basmachi successes, they regained control over all of Eastern Bukhara, most of Western Bukhara, Khorezm, and the entire Fergana Valley.[156][157][158]
Aftermath
By early June, insurgents under Enver Pasha advanced from Boysun, capturing Bolshevik positions at Chashma and Hazifan. By 6 June, Soviet forces in the region were estimated at 70,000, including 4,500 in Tashkent, 10,000 in Fergana, 5,000 in Semirechye, 7,000 in Khiva, 1,000 between Kizilsu and Ashkabad, 4,000 in Ashkabad, 3,000 between Ashkabad and Merv, 10,000 between Merv and Kushk, 3,500 in Chardzhou, 7,000 in the Kerki–Termez sector, and 15,000 along the Kogon–Karshi–Samarkand line.[159][160]
The Basmachis entered Termez again on 8 June but were pushed back after Soviet reinforcements arrived. Fighting continued in the surrounding area for twelve days, with heavy losses on both sides, including the death of Russian military commissar M. Marosin.[161] Enver's forces also captured Sherobod, inflicting heavy casualties on the Bolsheviks and prompting additional Soviet reinforcements to be sent.[59] Meanwhile, the Soviets transferred large numbers of troops to Turkestan via Kizilsu from the Caucasus and through the Orenburg railway, concentrating them around Kushk and partly in Bukhara, aiming to deter Afghanistan from supporting Enver Pasha.[59]
On 10 June 1922, the Soviets launched a new campaign against Enver, describing him as "the most evil enemy of Soviet power and defender of the interests of the manaps."[162] At that day, Enver Pasha successfully defended Kurganteppa and won the battle in Argamchi.[163]
Due to the deteriorating situation in Turkestan, Yakov Melkumov, commander of the 2nd Turkestan Cavalry Brigade, was dispatched to lead operations against the Basmachi movement.
On 21 June, Enver Pasha engaged with the Bolshevik forces to the west of Samarkand. His troops achieved a decisive victory, reportedly destroying two Red Army divisions.[164][165][166]
At the end of June, Enver Pasha attacked a bridgehead on the Surxondaryo River, defended by a battalion of the 5th Rifle Regiment. Several assaults led by Enver were repelled, and by 29 June, the entire regiment, supported by artillery, crossed the river and outflanked his forces. After an intense battle in which the Basmachis lost 165 men, Enver retreated.[167][168] The Red Army pursued Enver in two columns—one to seal the Afghan frontier and the other to envelop him from the north and expel him from the Hisar Valley.[169]
In July 1922, the forces of Faizal Maksum, supporters of Enver Pasha, were disarmed by the Basmachi in Karategin under the leadership of Ishan Sultan.[170] On 7 July, a Basmachi assassination attempt on the life of Fayzulla Xoʻjayev failed.[60][171]
During the same year and into the following one, the government of the Bukharan People's Soviet Republic dismissed all Ottoman prisoners of war working in Bukhara as teachers, officially accusing them of provoking factionalism in the country and supporting Enver's actions.[172][173][174][175]
Notes
- Ali Bademci gives **60,000** (Ali Bademci, Basmacı Arşiv Belgelerine Göre Türkistan'da Enver Paşa] (Istanbul: Kamer Yayınları, 2019), p. 306. (although this probably includes non-armed basmachis as well since Bademci uses the word "mujahid" which means one who struggles on behalf of Islam.)
- A Soviet archival source gives **26,000** (Central State Archive of the Soviet Army [CSASA], file 7, catalogue 2, dossier 466, p. 58).
- Salahi R. Sonyel, "Enver Paşa ve Orta Asya'da Başgösteren 'Basmacı' Akımı," Belleten 54, no. 211 (1990): 1179–1208, and Okan Yeşilot & Burcu Özdemir, "Sovyet Arşiv Belgeleri Işığında Basmacı Hareketi," Belleten 85, no. 302 (2021): 279–310, both suggest **around 20,000** (though these often refer to total Basmachi numbers in Central Asia, not only Enver's immediate forces).
- Marie Broxup, "The Basmachi," Central Asian Survey 2, no. 1 (1983): 57–81, gives **16,000** alongside Robert F. Baumann Russian-Soviet Unconventional Wars in the Caucasus, Central Asia, and Afghanistan (Fort Leavenworth: Combat Studies Institute, U.S. Army Command and General Staff College, 1993), Leavenworth Papers no. 20, p. 112
- Şevket Süreyya Aydemir, Enver Paşa: Makedonya'dan Orta Asya'ya (Istanbul: Remzi Kitabevi, 1970), p. 664, suggests a range of **12,400–7,465**.
- Glenda Fraser, "Basmachi I Central Asian Survey, 6:1" p.58 and H. B. Paksoy, "The Basmachi Movement From Within: An Account of Zeki Velidi Togan," Nationalities Papers 23, no. 2 (1995): p.392 suggests up to **7,000** in May 1922
Some Soviet writers even claimed that Mikhail Frunze faced **40,000** in Bukhara (Tsentralnaya Aziya i Zakavkaz'ye: Istoriya i Sovremennost', p. 64), but this figure is considered exaggerated and logistically impossible by Robert F. Baumann (p.121).
References
- ^ Until late spring or June
- ^
- Fraser (1987b), p. 59
- Hiro (2011), p. 42
- Broxup (2007b), p. 68
- Dagiev (2013c), For this very reason the Bolsheviks were forced to mobilize all forces to fight Enver Pasha. Central Asia was supplied with new military units, weapons and the most senior Bolshevik military commanders, such as Leon Trotsky, Lev Kamenev and Semyon Budyonny, to name but a few, were dispatched there and a large-scale military operation was organized against the rebels.
- ^ Fromkin 1989, p. 486.
- ^ Hopkirk 1995b, p. 158.
- ^ Fraser 1987b, p. 53.
- ^ Shalinsky 1982, p. 74.
- ^
- Hayit (2001a), p. 230
- Kara (2011), p. 133
- Bardakçı (2015a), p. 349
- Mould (2016b), p. 49
- ^
- Dixon (2016c), p. 473
- Broxup (2007b), p. 6
- Baumann (1993a), p. 100
- Jowett (2022b), p. 6
- ^ Bademci 2019a, p. 314.
- ^ Fraser 1987c, p. 16.
- ^ a b Kutay 1955, p. 55.
- ^ a b c Gürsoy 2007c, p. 362.
- ^ Cebesoy 2017a, p. 331.
- ^ Baysun 2001a, p. 109.
- ^ Bademci 2015d, p. 131, Düşenbe'de sıkışan Bolşevikler'e imdat için Dihnev'den gön-derilen bir bölük Rus süvârisi pusuya düşürüldü. Askerleri tesirsiz hale getirilerek, mitralyöz, tüfek ve cephane ganimetleri elde edildi. Gün geçtikçe işler ciddileşiyordu..
- ^ Bardakçı 2016, p. 452, İşte Naciyeciğim, bugün de geçti. Dün, Rahman Binbaşı'yı Kamçı Kışlağı'nda Ruslar basmak istemiş fakat muvaffak olamamışlar. Bizimkiler bir at almış ve Ruslar'a epey telefat verdirmişler ve onlan Düşenbe'ye kadar kovalamışlar..
- ^ Bardakçı 2015a, p. 340, Sana şu satırlan gecenin ikisinde Düşenbe kasabasından yazıyorum. Bugün öğleye doğru başlayan tipiden istifade ile Ruslar Düşenbe'yi terkle garba doğru savuşmuşlardır. İkindiye doğru haberimiz oldu. Fakat her vakit bu haber geldiğinden hemen Nafi Efendi'yi ileri karakol ile gönderdim ve arkasından vardık. Hakikaten, Ruslar çekilmiş.
- ^ a b Wheeler 1959a, p. 244.
- ^ Kara 2011, p. 128, Enver Paşa bu saldırıda 180 tüfek 2 mitralyöz ele geçirmiş 100 Rus askeri öldürülmüştür. Dahası Enver Paşa'ya 82 Basmacı daha katılacaktır.
- ^ Bazarbaev 2023b, p. 4.
- ^ Baysun 2001a, p. 95.
- ^ Hayit 2006, p. 275.
- ^
- Çelebi (2018d), p. 196, Enver Paşa’nın 1.500 kişilik bir kuvvetle Rusların 7.000–8.000 kişilik kuvvetlerine galebe çalması.
- Gümüş (2015e), p. 673, 1.500 kişilik bir kuvvetiyle 7–8.000 kişilik bir Rus askerî kuvvetini yendi.
- İdil (2013), p. 169
- İnan (1997), p. 118
- Yamauchi (1995a), pp. 262, Düşenbe’den çıkan Rusları takip ederek Mortebe, Şorab, Nevabad-Noda, Seşme, Sarıasıya, Anbarsay-yarı, Mirşadi’de Rusları vurduk... 50’den fazla ölü, aynı kadar yaralı.
- Bademci (2019a), p. 116, 70 kadar ölü, 2 mitralyöz, 16 tüfek bırakmışlardı.
- Kara (2011), p. 128, Cenab-ı Allah’ın yardımıyla Bolşevikleri Duşanbe, Yürci, Seriasyab, Dihnev ve Kabadiyan’dan çıkardık.
- Kandemir (1955b), p. 32, 19 Şubatta Seriasya civarında Ruslarla çarpışırken Enver Paşa yaralandı, fakat savaşmaya devam etti.
- Gürsoy (2007c), p. 363
- ^ Türk Tarih Kongresi: Kongrenin çalişmaları, kongreye sunulan tebliğler (in Turkish). Kenan Matbaası. 1993. p. 1522.
His first major victory is when he attacks Dushanbe on January 28, 1922, with 1500 soldiers against some 7 or 8000. After two weeks of fighting the occupying troops evacuate the town
- ^ a b texte, France Ministère de la guerre (1791–1936) Auteur du; texte, France Ministère des affaires étrangères (1588–2007) Auteur du (1922-06-01). "Bulletin périodique de la presse russe". Gallica. Retrieved 2025-11-03.
{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link) - ^ a b Fraser 1987b, p. 58.
- ^ Wheeler 1956b, p. 175, preference of Indian Muslims the question arose as to who was in fact to command the Indian army once India had won her independence, the almost unanimous answer was heard: Of course, 'Enver Pasha!'..
- ^ Martin 1998a, p. 829, Major uprisings also flared up in other Soviet border regions: in Chechnia and Dagestan from 1920 to 1922...
- ^ a b Kara 2011, p. 132.
- ^ Kutay 1955, pp. 60–61.
- ^ Исалабдулаев 2016e, p. 62, Для борьбы с отрядами Н. Гоцинского 30 января 1922 г. в Дагестане было образовано Республиканское военное совещание по борьбе с бандитизмом. В августе 1922 г. Дагестан был объявлен на военном положении..
- ^ a b Donogo 2008d, p. 137.
- ^ Donogo 2008d, pp. 136–137.
- ^ BCA (Başbakanlık Cumhuriyet Arşivi), 23 August 1922, File: 431 II, Fund Code: 30.10.0.0, Location No: 247.671.11
- ^ Ю.А 1976, pp. 94–95.
- ^ a b c d Sonyel 1990a, p. 54.
- ^ Hayit 2018a, p. 208.
- ^
- Yamauchi (1995a), pp. 268–269
- Cebesoy (2017a), p. 333
- Tuğlacı (1987d), p. 568
- Bardakçı (2015a), p. 351, “Türkistan Cephesi Kumandanı'nın bir emrini elde ettim. Bunda dördüncü, beşinci nişancı alaylarından bahsediyor ki bunlar yeni gelmiş olacaklardır. Bir de Buhara'dan çıkmış olan birinci ve ikinci süvari alayları da gelmiş. Maamafih karşımdaki bütün Rus kuvveti azamî beş bin kişidir. Buna mukabil elimde şimdilik azamî beşyüz tüfek var. Fakat tedricen artmaktadır ve herhalde inşaallah mahcup olmam.”
- ^ Yamauchi 1995a, pp. 267–268.
- ^ Yalvar 2017c, p. 230.
- ^ Hatunoğlu 2016a, p. 322.
- ^ RGASPI,f.544,op.4,d.29,l12-13
- ^
- Karpov (2018c), p. 57
- Castagné (1925d), p. 51
- Bademci (2019a), p. 122, “çok zayiat verdiler... Şimdilik toplanan kuvvetlerimiz 3000 atlıyı bulur.”
- ^ a b Russian State Military Archive (RGVA), fond 272, inventory 2, file 97, page 41.
- ^ Bademci 2008b, pp. 145–147.
- ^ RGASPI,f.558,op.11,d.29,l.15–16
- ^ RGASPI, f. 62, op. 2, d. 88, l. 111–111ob
- ^ "Тайная сделка советской власти с главным "басмачом" Средней Азии". BBC News Русская служба (in Russian). Retrieved 2025-10-31.
Начальник Душанбинского гарнизона Владимир Мартыновский в донесении штабу Туркестанского фронта сообщал о критическом положении, в котором оказались красноармейцы, и просил скорейшей помощи: "Болезни и истощение вывели из строя 80% личного состава. Десятки красноармейцев убиты и ранены. Осуществить прорыв из плотного кольца окружения практически невозможно".
- ^ Sonyel 1990, p. 1185.
- ^ FO 371/8074/N 4613. Kew, London: The National Archives (UK).
- ^ RGASPI, fond 62, opis 2, file 22, folio 1
- ^ Hayit 1956a, p. 186.
- ^ Dagiev 2013c, For this very reason the Bolsheviks were forced to mobilize all forces to fight Enver Pasha. Central Asia was supplied with new military units, weapons and the most senior Bolshevik military commanders, such as Leon Trotsky, Lev Kamenev and Semyon Budyonny, to name but a few, were dispatched there and a large-scale military operation was organized against the rebels..
- ^ Ferghana Oblast State Archive, Fund 435, index I, item 140, sheet 147.
- ^
- Bardakçı (2016), p. 546
- Özdemir (2007), p. 278
- Baysun (2001a), p. 65
- ^ Russian State Archive of Socio-Political History (RGASPI), f. 62, op. 2, d. 5, l. 231.
- ^ KC MDA, Fund No. 2225, Record No. 2, File No. 45, pp. 115–120.
- ^ These numbers are disputed. According to a report from Nabi Baksh, Enver received only 150 rifles and ten boxes of ammunition (British Library, India Office Records (IOR), Political and Secret Department, File 1919/57: Statement by Nabi Baksh, 13 December 1923). Another account claims that General Nadir Khan sent Enver 60,000 rupees and 300 armed men to serve as a guard, together with a limited supply of cartridges, but Enver refused the 300 men, frustrated that the two artillery pieces he had requested were not provided by the Amir (British Library, India Office Records (IOR), Political and Secret Department, File 1919/57: Statement by Sayyid Ibadulla, 27 February 1923).
- ^ a b c d Sonyel 1990a, p. 58.
- ^ a b c Rywkin 1990c, p. 39.
- ^ RGASPI. F. 2, op. 1, d. 23181, l. 2.
- ^
- Dixon (2016c), p. 473
- Arabacı (2021b), p. 25
- İdil (2013), p. 227
- Shahingoz (2020a), p. 31
- ^ Başbakanlık Cumhuriyet Arşivi (BCA), 23/8/1922, File: 43111, Background File: 30.10.0.0, Location number: 247.671.11
- ^ RGASPI,f.558,op.11,d.29,l.50–51
- ^ Yeşilot 2021, p. 288.
- ^ a b c d e Olcott 1981a, p. 359.
- ^ Johnson 1986, p. 33.
- ^ Kydyralieva 2015b, p. 242.
- ^ Arslan 2010, p. 51, Bir fişek ve mermi (kartuş) imalathanesi kurdu. Bununla, büyük bir derde çare bulmuş oluyordu. Silah, cephane ve diğer askeri malzemeleri eksik olmasına rağmen Ruslarla savaşa tutuşmak durumunda kaldı ... Türkistan'ı oluşturan dokuz vilayetten beşini işgal ettiler..
- ^ Kara 2011, pp. 131.
- ^ Kutay 1955, p. 60.
- ^
- Karabekir (2024e), p. 742, “İstanbul gazeteleri Şarkî Buhara'da Enver Paşa'nın Sovyet Rusya süvari kumandanı Yudeni'yi perişan ettiğini yazıyor.”
- Sonyel (1990), p. 1195
- Hayit (1956a), p. 193
- Baysun (2001a), p. 115
- ^ FO 371/8074/N 5478: Encrypted telegram from Humphrys to Curzon, Kabul, 29 May 1922
- ^ a b "Enver Pasha as Emir of Turkestan". Current History. 16 (6): 951–952. 1922. ISSN 2641-080X. JSTOR 45326897.
- ^ a b "Islamism threatens to drive out reds" (PDF). 29 July 1922.
...by the end of May [he] started a double offensive northeast from Bokhara, which he had captured by a brilliant coup de main, toward Tashkent and northeast from Hisar to Khokand ... and now holds loosely the line from Tashkent down to Khojent and eastward through Kokand to Naryn, whence he is sending out flying columns that threaten the Tashkent and Krasnovodsk Railway ... The entire country south of Tash-kent has been wrested from the Reds, including the Important towns of Yar-kand, Kashgar, Samarkand and Bokhara
- ^ "ENVER IN TURAN". New York Times. 31 July 1922. p. 8.
A recent report from Tashkend says that he now oc-cupies a region about the size of Texas.
- ^ Ю.А 1976, p. 94.
- ^ Smele 2017a, p. 271.
- ^ a b c d Wheeler 1959a, p. 245.
- ^ Lageard 1987a, p. 8.
- ^ Yılmaz 1999c, p. 58.
- ^ David 1992a, p. 220.
- ^ Мышов 2022, p. 87.
- ^ a b Ю.А 1976, p. 98.
- ^ a b c Bogdanov 1997, p. 87.
- ^ Kotelnikov 2024d, p. 14.
- ^ Kotelnikov 2024d, p. 15.
- ^ RGASPI,f.17,op.84,d.356,l.70
- ^ a b Donuk 1992c, p. 108.
- ^ Bademci 2008a, p. 393.
- ^ Erer 1971b, p. 71.
- ^ Hayit 2018a, p. 207.
- ^ Fromkin 1989, p. 488.
- ^
- Fromkin (1989), p. 488
- Ю.А (1976), p. 95
- Fraser (1987c), pp. 37–38
- Yılmaz (1999c), pp. 49–50
- Castagné (1925d), pp. 49–50
- ^ a b Hayit 1956a, pp. 194–195.
- ^ Rezun 1992b, p. 30.
- ^ RGASPI. F. 17, op. 3, 293, l. 9.
- ^ Kydyralieva 2015b, p. 242..
- ^ Fraser 1987c, pp. 14–16.
- ^ Kydyralieva 2015b, p. 243..
- ^ a b Muradjon, Nurmuhamedov (2024-10-20). "OCCUPATION OF BUKHARA EMIRATE BY TSARIST RUSSIA". American Journal of Pedagogical and Educational Research. 29: 43. ISSN 2832-9791.
- ^ Sonyel 1990, p. 1189.
- ^ Togan 1981, p. 446.
- ^ Kydyralieva 2015b, p. 243.
- ^ Nabiyev, Muhammadali (July 11, 2022). "International Scientific Journal "Science and Innovation". Series C." International Scientific Journal. 1 (3): 300.
- ^ "Mulla Abdulqahhor" (PDF). Oʻzbekiston Milliy Ensiklopediyasi (in Uzbek). Vol. M. Tashkent: Oʻzbekiston Milliy Ensiklopediyasi Davlat Ilmiy Nashriyoti. 2003. p. 803.
- ^ Sattorov 2025, p. 227..
- ^ Rywkin 1990c, p. 39..
- ^ Raşidov, U. (1994). "Buhara basmacıları aslı kim idi?" [Who Were the Basmachi of Bukhara?]. Mülakat (in Turkish) (11–12): 35.
- ^ Kydyralieva 2015b, p. 244..
- ^ Hopkirk 1995b, p. 159.
- ^ Hayit 2006, p. 289.
- ^ T.B.M.M. Gizli Celse Zabıtları, c.3,s. 838, 839, 840
- ^ Kotelnikov 2024d, p. 13.
- ^ a b Kydyralieva 2015b, p. 260.
- ^ Gutliyev 2017a, p. 50.
- ^ For example, Kydyralieva gives the number of troops under Junaid Khan as 1918 in the page 219, meanwhile "K. B. Muhammetberdiyew/Y. Orazgylyjow, Türkmenistanyn Taryhyndan Materiallar" book gives 4,000 and ÇELEBİ, Ercan Yaş Türkistan Dergisine Göre Türkistan Milli Mücadelesi even gives 80,000 in page 157 of his thesis.
- ^ a b Bademci 2008b, p. 412.
- ^ Wheeler 1964, p. 110.
- ^ Emre Esen, Türkistan'da Basmacılık Hareketi p.62
- ^ Alimova 2000, p. 624.
- ^ RGASPI,f.122,op.4,d.59,l.93-94ob
- ^ a b c Hayit 2018a, p. 205.
- ^ Olcott 1981a, p. 357.
- ^
- Castagné (1925d), p. 51
- Hayit (2006), p. 277
- Bademci (2008b), p. 122
- Kösoğlu (2023), p. 623
- T.B.M.M. Gizli Celse Zabıtları, c.3,s. 838, 839, 840
- ^ Kotelnikov 2024d, pp. 13–15.
- ^ Bademci 2008b, pp. 132–133.
- ^ Bademci 2015d, p. 142.
- ^ Bademci 2019a, p. 145.
- ^ Bademci 2008b, pp. 156–158.
- ^ Bademci 2015d, p. 148.
- ^ Baysun 2001a, pp. 92–93.
- ^ a b Doğan 1998, p. 108.
- ^ Kara 2011, p. 134.
- ^ Cebesoy 2017a, p. 335.
- ^ Erer 1971b, pp. 122–123.
- ^ Fraser 1987b, p. 42.
- ^ Hayit 2018a, pp. 209–213.
- ^ Fraser 1987c, pp. 34–37.
- ^ Kydyralieva 2015b, p. 244.
- ^ Fraser 1987b, p. 54.
- ^ Allworth 1967, p. 252.
- ^ Kydyralieva 2015b, p. 245.
- ^ Hayit 2018a, p. 283.
- ^ Hayit 2018a, pp. 205–206.
- ^ Fraser 1987b, pp. 59, 72.
- ^ a b Hayit 1956a, p. 202.
- ^ Shermatov, Gafur (20 December 2017). "Тайная сделка советской власти с главным "басмачом" Средней Азии" [The Secret Deal of the Soviet Authorities with the Main "Basmachi" of Central Asia]. BBC News, Russian Service. Retrieved 13 September 2025.
- ^ Krivosheev 1997, p. 30.
- ^ Ferghana Oblast State Archive, Fund 435, index I, item 133, sheet 80.
- ^ "During February–October 1922, the Red Army destroyed 119 Basmachi detachments (4 thousand people) out of 200." Check Krugosvet, Vadim Damier Basmach Movement (source is unavailable for now)
- ^ GARF,f.R5325,op.4,d.77,l.9 "басмачам в Западной Бухаре, уничтожив ряд крупнейших курбашей. Затем сам глава западно-бухарского басмачества мулла Абдул-Кагар терпит два поражения. Начинают сдаваться один за другим крубаши – сначала мелкие, а потом и более крупные, в общем за октябрь (1922 г. – Я.С.) сдалось до 250 басмачей. Сейчас в Западной Бухаре осталась шайка Абдул-Кагара до 100 чел., ранее доходившая чуть ли не до 1000, и Мурат-Машкапа – до 150 чел.»"
- ^ Плеханов, Александр Михайлович (15 March 2024). "Басмачество". Большая российская энциклопедия (in Russian). АНО «Национальный научно-образовательный центр «Большая Российская энциклопедия». Retrieved 15 October 2025.
советские войска провели операцию по окружению и уничтожению отрядов Энвер-паши, сам он был убит в бою. Численность басмачей, по оценке советской разведки, сократилась с 26 тыс. человек в мае до 6,7 тыс. человек в октябре 1922 г.
- ^ Malikov 2020b, p. 173, Report of the chairman of the commission on the extermination of basmachis sokol'nikov to the central committee of the communist party: Basmachi movement is a reproach to all our work in Turkestan, and maybe even in the entire East. We have fought hard against the Basmachis for four years. However, we failed to suppress this movement. On the contrary, the Basmachi movement expanded to other raions, and now it covers entire Samarkand Oblast and some parts of Syr-Daria and Turkmen Oblast's..
- ^ Rossiiskii Gosudarstvennyi Arkhiv Sotsial'no Politicheskoi Istorii (hereafter RGASPI) [Russian State Archive of the Social Political History], fond 122, op. 1, d. 228. ll. 1-1ob.
- ^
- Arslan (2010), p. 51, Türkistan'ı oluşturan dokuz vilayetten beşini işgal ettiler.
- Castagné (1925d), p. 51
- Baumann (1993a), p. 112
- Yeşilot (2021), p. 288
- Tannenbaum (2023a), p. 63
- Johnson (1986), p. 33
- Hayit (2006), p. 277
- Krist (1939a), p. 78
- Arabacı (2021b), p. 25
- Schoeberlein-Engel (2009), "At its height (1920–1922), the Basmachi movement was in control of the entire Ferghana Valley, aside from Russian railroad and military installations, as well as most of what is now Tajikistan and some other areas."
- ^ "Basmachi". Encyclopedia.com. Retrieved 2025-10-17.
At their height in 1920–1922, some sources claim that the rebels had twenty to thirty thousand men under arms, controlled the Ferghana valley and most of Tajikistan, and enjoyed widespread popularity among the indigenous non-Russian population.
- ^ Entsiklopedik Luğat, vol. 2 (Tashkent: Özbek Sovet Entsiklopediyasi, 1988), p. 117: "In the spring of 1922, the Basmachi occupied much of the Bukhara People's Soviet Republic; similar movements also occurred in Ferghana and Khorezm at that time."
- ^ FO 371/8074/N 6007, Confidential telegram from the Commander-in-Chief in India to the War Office, 13 June 1922.
- ^ Sonyel 1990, p. 1195.
- ^ FO 371/8080/N 8484, India Office to Foreign Office, dispatch, enclosing Secret Meshed Intelligence Diary, No.22, for the period ending 17 July 1922. Kew, London: The National Archives (UK).
- ^ Fraser 1987b, p. 41.
- ^ Hayit 2018a, p. 219.
- ^ "Enver Paşa'nın Yeni bir Muvaffakiyeti," Liva el-İslam, Year 2, no. 15–16, p. 102, 1 Teşrin-i Ewel 1922.
- ^ BCA, 23/8/1922, Dosya: 43111, Fon Kodu: 30.10.0.0, Yer No: 247.671.11
- ^ İdil 2013, p. 227.
- ^ Fraser 1987b, p. 60.
- ^ Kozlovskiy 1928, p. 53.
- ^ Baumann 1993a, pp. 112–113.
- ^ Fraser 1987b, p. 61.
- ^ Castagné 1925d, p. 59.
- ^ Tsentral'nyi Gosudarstvennyi Arkhiv Respubliki Uzbekistan (Central State Archive of the Republic of Uzbekistan), fond. 48, delo. 103, l. 28ob
- ^ Russian State Archive of Socio-Political History (RGASPI), fond. 62, opis 1, delo. 7, list. 71 (19.03.1923)
- ^ BNSR Foreign Ministry to Representation of the Turkish Grand National Assembly, Moscow, 18 June 1922, TsGARUz, f. 48, op. 1, d. 103, ll. 28-28ob
- ^ Khalid 2015b, p. 154.
Sources
- Adle, Chahryar (2005a). History of Civilizations of Central Asia: Towards the Contemporary Period: From the Mid-Nineteenth to the End of the Twentieth Century. Vol. VI. UNESCO.
- Alimova, Dilorom Agzamovna (2000). Turkestan v nachale XX veka: k istorii istokov natsional'noĭ nezavisimosti (in Russian). Shark.
- Bademci, Ali (2008a). 1917–1934 Türkistan Milli İstiklal Hareketi: Korbaşılar ve Enver Paşa 1. cilt (in Turkish). Ötüken Neşriyat. ISBN 978-975-437-677-7.
- Bademci, Ali (2008b). 1917–1934 Türkistan Milli İstiklal Hareketi: Korbaşılar ve Enver Paşa 2. cilt (in Turkish). Ötüken Neşriyat. ISBN 978-975-437-677-7.
- Bademci, Ali (2015d). Sarıklı Basmacı: Türkistan'da Enver Paşa'nın Umumi Muhaberat Müdürü Molla Nafiz'in Hatıraları (in Turkish). Ötüken Neşriyat. ISBN 978-975-437-766-8.
- Bademci, Ali (2019a). Basmacı Arşiv Belgelerine Göre Türkistan'da Enver Paşa (in Turkish). Kamer Yayınları. ISBN 978-605-69700-5-4.
- Bardakçı, Murat (2015a). Enver (in Turkish). Türkiye İş Bankası Kültür Yayınları.
- Bardakçı, Murat (2016). Naciyem, Ruhum, Efendim… (in Turkish). Türkiye İş Bankası Kültür Yayınları. ISBN 978-605-332-727-1.
- Baysun, Abdullah Recep (2001a). Türkistan'da istiklâl hareketleri ve Enver Paşa (in Turkish). Turan Kültür Vakfı. ISBN 978-975-7893-32-5.
- Beckett, Ian, ed. (2017). Modern Counter-Insurgency. Taylor & Francis. ISBN 9781351917025.
- Baumann, Robert F. (1993a). Russian-Soviet Unconventional Wars in the Caucasus, Central Asia, and Afghanistan (PDF). Leavenworth Papers #20. US Army Command and General Staff College.
- Doğan, Cabir (1998). Enver Paşa'nın yurt dışındaki hayatı ve mücadelesi (in Turkish).
- Erer, Tekin (1971b). Enver Paşa'nın Türkistan Kurtuluş Savaşı (in Turkish). Mayataş Yayınları.
- Fromkin, David (1989). A Peace to End All Peace: The Fall of the Ottoman Empire and the Creation of the Modern Middle East (PDF). Henry Holt and Company.
- Gutliyev, Gurbangeldi (2017a). Türkmenistanda basmacı (Milli direniş) hareketi ve Cüneyt Han (in Turkish).
- Hatunoğlu, Nurettin (2016a). Türkistan'da Son Türk Devleti: Buhara Emirliği ve Alim Han (in Turkish). Ötüken Neşriyat. ISBN 978-975-437-842-9.
- Hayit, Baymirza (1956a). Turkestan im XX. Jahrhundert (in German). C. W. Leske.
- Hayit, Baymirza (2001a). Sovyetlerde Türklüğün ve İslam'ın Bazı Meseleleri (in Turkish). Türk Dünyası Araştırmaları Vakfı. ISBN 978-975-498-149-0.
- Hayit, Baymirza (2006). Basmacılar / Ruslara Karşı Basmacılar Hareketi (in Turkish). Babıali Kültür Yayıncılığım. ISBN 978-975-00981-9-2.
- Hayit, Baymirza (2018a). (Basmacılar) Türkistan Milli Mücadele Tarihi (1917–1934) (in Turkish). Türkıstanlı Kütüphanesi.
- İdil, Aydın (2013). Enver Paşa'nın son savaşı: Basmacı hareketinin önderi Seyyid Enver Emir-i Leşker-i İslam (in Turkish). Kitabevi. ISBN 978-605-5397-67-8.
- Kara, İlyas (2011). Enver Paşa: Basmacılar İsyanı (in Turkish). Yediveren Yayınları. ISBN 978-605-88203-6-4.
- Khalid, Adeeb (2015b). Making Uzbekistan: Nation, Empire, and Revolution in the Early USSR. Cornell University Press. ISBN 978-1-5017-3585-1. JSTOR 10.7591/j.ctt20fw5rf.
- Kösoğlu, Nevzat (2023). Şehit Enver Paşa (in Turkish). Ötüken Neşriyat. ISBN 978-975-437-681-4.
- Kotelnikov, Vladimir (2024d). Soviet Military Aviation in Central Asia 1917–41. Helion and Company. ISBN 9781804516423.
- Kutay, Cemal (1955). Enver Paşa Lenin'e Karşı (in Turkish).
- David, Roger (1992a). Faizulla Khodzhaev : national communism in Bukhara and Soviet Uzbekistan, 1896–1938.
- Kydyralieva, Saltanat (2015b). Türk ve Rus kaynaklarına göre Türkistan'da Basmacı Hareketi (1916–1924) (in Turkish). Ulusal Tez Merkezi.
- Ю.А, Поляков (1976). Конец басмачества. Ohio University Press.
- Mould, David H. (2016b). Postcards from Stanland. Ohio University Press. ISBN 978-0821421772.
- Olimhon, Amir Said. Buhara halkının hasreti tarihi (in Turkish).
- Özdemir, Hikmet (2007). Üç Jöntürk'ün Ölümü: Talat – Cemal – Enver (in Turkish). Remzi Kitabevi. ISBN 978-975-14-1223-2.
- Rezun, Miron (1992b). Intrigue and War in Southwest Asia: The Struggle for Supremacy from Central Asia to Iraq. Praeger. ISBN 978-0-275-94105-5.
- Rywkin, Michael (1990c). Moscow's Muslim Challenge: Soviet Central Asia. M. E. Sharpe. ISBN 0873326148.
- Tannenbaum, Ben (2023a). Fate Saw the Jewel: Enver Pasha's Post-War Intrigues, 1918–1922. United States Military Academy.
- Togan, Zeki Velidi (1981). Bugünkü Türkili (Türkistan) ve Yakın Tarihi (in Turkish). Vol. 1.
- Turlybek, Aslan (2013a). Enver Paşa 1918–1922 (Thesis) (in Turkish). T.C. Ankara Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü.
- Wheeler, Geoffrey (1964). The Modern History of Soviet Central Asia (PDF). Frederick A. Praeger.
- Yamauchi, Masayuki (1995a). Hoşnut Olamamış Adam: Enver Paşa – Türkiye'den Türkistan'a (in Turkish). Bağlam Yayıncılık. ISBN 9789757696759.
- Johnson, David Ray (1986). Soviet Counterinsurgency (PDF). Defense Technical Information Center. Retrieved 2025-11-02.
- Broxup, Marie (2007b). "The Basmachi". Central Asian Survey. 2 (1): 57–81. doi:10.1080/02634938308400421.
- Castagné, Joseph (1925d). "Les Basmatchis: le mouvement national des indigènes d'Asie Centrale depuis la Révolution d'octobre 1917 jusqu'en octobre 1924". L'Asie française (in French).
- Lageard, Helene Aymen (1987a). "The revolt of the basmachi according to red army journals (1920–1922)". Central Asian Survey. 6 (3): 1–35. doi:10.1080/02634938708400590.
- Dixon, Jeffrey S. (2016c). A guide to intra-state wars: an examination of civil, regional, and intercommunal wars, 1816–2014. doi:10.4135/9781483399403 (inactive 21 December 2025). ISBN 978-0-87289-775-5.
{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: DOI inactive as of December 2025 (link) - Fraser, Glenda (1987b). "Basmachi — I". Central Asian Survey. 6 (1): 1–73. doi:10.1080/02634938708400571.
- Fraser, Glenda (1987c). "Basmachi — II". Central Asian Survey. 6 (2): 7–42. doi:10.1080/02634938708400582.
- Olcott, Martha B. (1981a). "The Basmachi or Freemen's Revolt in Turkestan 1918–24". Soviet Studies. 33 (3): 352–369. doi:10.1080/09668138108411365. JSTOR 151077.
- Shalinsky, Audrey C. (1982). "Islam and Ethnicity: The Northern Afghanistan Perspective". Central Asian Survey. 1 (2–3): 71–83. doi:10.1080/02634938208400397.
- Sonyel, S. R. (1990a). "Enver Pasha and the Basmaji movement in Central Asia". Middle Eastern Studies. 26 (1): 52–64. doi:10.1080/00263209008700804.
- Sonyel, Salahi R. (1990). "Enver Paşa ve Orta Asya'da Başgösteren "Basmacı" Akımı". Belleten (in Turkish). 54 (211): 1179–1208. doi:10.37879/belleten.1990.1179. ISSN 0041-4255.
- Yılmaz, Şuhnaz (1999c). "An Ottoman warrior abroad: Enver Paşa as an expatriate". Middle Eastern Studies. 35 (4): 40–69. doi:10.1080/00263209908701286.
- Yeşilot, Okan (2021). "Sovyet Arşiv Belgeleri Işığında Basmacı Hareketi". Belleten (in Turkish). 85 (302): 279–309. doi:10.37879/belleten.2021.279.
- "Enver Pasha as Emir of Turkestan". Current History. 16 (6): 951. 1922a. ISSN 2641-080X. JSTOR 45326897.
- Shahingoz, Mehmet (2020a). "Some aspects of the "Basmachi" movement and the role of Enver Pasha in Turkestan". Journal of History. 97 (2). doi:10.26577/jh.2020.v97.i2.03.
- "Central Asian Review, Vol. VII (Index and Articles)" (PDF). Central Asian Review. 7. 1959.
- "Bulletin périodique de la presse russe". Bulletin périodique de la presse russe (in French). 1922b.
- Cebesoy, Ali Fuat (2017a). Kocahanoğlu, Osman Selim (ed.). Moskova Hatıraları: Millî Mücadele ve Bolşevik Rusya (in Turkish). İstanbul: Temel Yayınları. ISBN 9789754100679.
- Smele, Jonathan D. (2017a). The "Russian" Civil Wars, 1916–1926: Ten Years That Shook the World. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-873479-6.
- Arabacı, Hakan (2021b). Hariçteki Türkistan dergilerine göre basmacılık ve Ermeni meselesi [Basmachi movement and Armenian issue according to Turkestan magazines abroad] (Thesis) (in Turkish). Hacettepe Üniversitesi, Türkiyat Araştırmaları Enstitüsü.
- Krist, Gustav (1939a). Alone Through The Forbidden Land. Reader's Union.
- Мышов, Н.А. (2022). "Ликвидация лидера басмачества Энвера-Паши" [The Elimination of the Basmachi Leader Enver Pasha]. Восточный Архив [Eastern Archive] (in Russian). 2 (46).
- Bogdanov, V. N. (1997). Армия и Внутренние Войска в Противоповстанческой и Противопартизанской Борьбе. Мировой Опыт и Современность [The Army and Internal Troops in Counter-Rebellion and Anti-Partisan Warfare: Global Experience and the Present] (in Russian). Moscow: Main Command of Internal Troops of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia.
- Donuk, Abdülkadir (1992c). "Basmacı Hareketi" (PDF). İslam Ansiklopedisi (in Turkish). Vol. 5. Türkiye Diyanet Vakfı.
- Sattorov, Sarvar (2025). Mulla Abdulqahhorning yurtga xizmati (in Uzbek). doi:10.5281/zenodo.17249365.
- Yalvar, Cihan (2017c). "1918–1922 Yılları Arasında Emir Timur'un Mirası "Buhara Hanlığı"". Türk-İslam Dünyası Sosyal Araştırmalar Dergisi (in Turkish). 4 (10): 213–233. doi:10.16989/TIDSAD.1234. ISSN 2149-083X.
- Kozlovskiy, E. (1928). Krasnaya armiya v Sredney Azii: Voenno-istoricheskiy ocherk (in Russian). Tashkent: Polituprovlenie Sredne-Aziatskogo Voyennogo Okruga.
- Schoeberlein-Engel, John S. (2009). "Basmachis". The Oxford Encyclopedia of the Islamic World. New York: Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780195305135.
- Karpov, G. I. (2018c). Aşirov, Tahir (ed.). "БОРЬБА С БАСМАЧЕСТВОМ В ТУРКМЕНИИ В ПЕРИОД 1920–24 [Struggle with Basmachi in Turkmenistan in the Period 1920–24]" [Struggle with the Basmachi in Turkmenistan, 1920–1924]. Asya Studies – Academic Social Studies (in Russian). 6 (Winter). Zonguldak Bülent Ecevit University. doi:10.31455/asya.426754.
- Karabekir, Kazım (2024e). Günlükler: 1906–1948 (in Turkish). Vol. 2. İstanbul: Yapı Kredi Yayınları. ISBN 9789750816895.
- Hopkirk, Peter (1995b). Setting the East ablaze : Lenin's dream of an empire in Asia. ISBN 1568361025.
- Jowett, Philip (2022b). The Red Army 1922–41: From Civil War to 'Barbarossa'. Bloomsbury Publishing. ISBN 9781472850447.
- Hiro, Dilip (2011). Inside Central Asia: A Political and Cultural History of Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkey, and Iran. New York: ABRAMS, Incorporated. ISBN 9781590203781.
- Riordan, John (2012). Red DIME: Dissecting the Bolshevik Liquidation Campaign in the Ferghana Valley Against the Basmachi Resistance (Thesis).
- Malikov, Yuriy (2020b). Modern Central Asia: A Primary Source Reader. Lanham, Maryland: Lexington Books. ISBN 9781793612175.
- Allworth, Edward (1967). Central Asia : a century of Russian rule. Newyork: Columbia University Press.
- Исалабдулаев, М. А. (2016e). История Дагестана (PDF) (in Russian). Махачкала: Дагестанский НИИ педагогики.
- Donogo, M. M. (2008d). "Н. Гоцинский и повстанческая борьба в Дагестане и Чечне (1922–1925 гг.)" [N. Gotsinsky and the Insurgent Struggle in Dagestan and Chechnya (1922–1925)]. Новый Исторический Вестник (in Russian). 18.
- İnan, Arı (1997). Enver Paşa'nın Özel Mektupları (in Turkish). İmge Kitabevi Yayınları. ISBN 9789755331874.
- Kandemir, Feridun (1955b). Enver Paşa'nın Son Günleri (in Turkish). İstanbul: Güven Basım ve Yayınevi.
- Gürsoy, Selçuk (2007c). Enver Paşa'nın Sürgünü: İhtilalci İslam Birliği ve Liva el-İslam Dergisi (in Turkish). İstanbul: Salyangoz Yayınları. ISBN 9789756277676.
- Gümüş, Musa (2015e). "TÜRKİSTAN'DA "VATAN" MÜDAFAACILARI: KORBAŞILAR HAREKETİ VE ENVER PAŞA" [Defenders of the Homeland in Turkestan: The Korbashi Movement and Enver Pasha] (PDF). Tarih Okulu Dergisi (Journal of History School) (in Turkish). 8 (XXIV). doi:10.14225/Joh816.
- Martin, Terry (1998a). "The Origins of Soviet Ethnic Cleansing". The Journal of Modern History. 70 (4). The University of Chicago Press: 813–861. doi:10.1086/235168. JSTOR 10.1086/235168.
- Arslan, Emir Şekip (2010). Sürgünde Üç Ölüm (in Turkish). İstanbul: Truva Yayınları. ISBN 9786059850438.
- Tuğlacı, Pars (1987d). Çağdaş Türkiye (in Turkish). Vol. 1. İstanbul: Cem Yayınevi.
- Çelebi, Ercan (2018d). Türkistan millî mücadelesi: Yaş Türkistan dergisine göre (in Turkish). İstanbul: Hiperlink Yayınları. ISBN 978-605-2137-64-2.
- Krivosheev, Grigori F. (1997). Soviet Casualties and Combat Losses in the Twentieth Century. Pennsylvania: Stackpole Books. ISBN 978-1-85367-280-4.
- Bazarbaev, Kanat (2023b). "Political Activity of Enver Pasha in the Turkestan National Liberation Movement". Vestnik KazNPU imeni Abaya. Series: Historical and Socio-Political Sciences (in Russian). 3 (78). doi:10.51889/2959-6017.2023.78.3.029.
- Dagiev, Dagikhudo (2013c). Regime Transition in Central Asia: Stateness, Nationalism and Political Change in Tajikistan and Uzbekistan. Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group. ISBN 9781134600762.
- Wheeler, Geoffrey (1956b). "Central Asian Review". Central Asian Review. 4. Central Asian Research Centre: 175.
- Wheeler, Geoffrey (1959a). "Central Asian Review" (PDF). Central Asian Review. 7. Central Asian Research Centre.