Convoy HX 231
| Convoy HX.231 | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Part of the Second World War | |||||
North Atlantic Ocean map | |||||
| |||||
| Belligerents | |||||
| Germany | |||||
| Commanders and leaders | |||||
| Karl Dönitz |
| ||||
| Strength | |||||
| 11 U-boats |
| ||||
| Casualties and losses | |||||
| 2 U-boats sunk | 6 ships sunk | ||||
Convoy HX 231 was the 231st of the numbered series of Second World War HX convoys of merchant ships from HalifaX to Liverpool. The ships departed New York City on 25 March 1943 and were met on 31 March by Mid-Ocean Escort Force Group B-7. The convoy was found on 4 April and attacked by eleven U-boats of the 1st, 3rd, 6th and 10th U-boat flotillas, from Brest, La Rochelle, St Nazaire and Lorient, respectively. These U-boats formed wolfpack Löwenherz (Lionheart). The U-boats sank six ships before losing contact on 7 April, U-632 and U-635, were sunk. The convoy reached Liverpool on 10 April.
Background
Convoy organisation 1942
In 1942, convoys west of 26° West came under the command of the US Vice-Admiral Arthur Bristol along with the escort forces in the western North Atlantic as Task Force 24. The Canadian Western Local Escort Force (WLEF, also Task Group 24.18) was under the tactical command of the Commanding Officer Atlantic Coast, Rear-Admiral Leonard Murray at Halifax, Nova Scotia, comprising 25 Canadian and 13 British destroyers and corvettes that escorted convoys from Halifax to the Western Ocean Meeting Point (WOMP) at 49° West when SC convoys began sailing from Halifax.[1]
The Mid-Ocean Escort Force (MOEF) was based at St John's Newfoundland and Londonderry and Liverpool in the British Isles and became Task Group 24.1, with seven British, four Canadian and one US Navy escort groups. The MOEF escorted HX, SC, ON and ONS convoys to the Eastern Ocean Meeting Point (EASTOMP) at about 20° West where the convoy was handed over to the Eastern local Escort Groups. Ships to Iceland the base for Task Group 24.6 with two US escort groups, detached at about 25° West (ICOMP). The mainly old coastguard ships escorting convoys on the Sydney to Greenland leg came under Task Force 24 as Task Group 24.9.[1]
When the US established the Interlocking Convoy System along the east coast and the Caribbean, the northern termination was at New York and from September 1942 the port became the departure point for transatlantic convoys. The Western Atlantic escort forces were insufficient for the leg from New York to the WOMP and a new Halifax Ocean Meeting Point (HOMP) was created around 61° West, where the eventual twelve WLEF groups (Task Group 24.18) were relieved. After April 1942 an attempt had been made to keep the Ocean Escort Groups together to reap the benefits of teamwork and experience and in the summer of 1942 led to EASTOMP being moved west to accommodate British escorts being sent to the Caribbean. The British escort groups B1 to B7 became based permanently in Britain and the Canadian groups C1 to C4, with the US group A3, at St John's. to the west of 26° West, the Change of Operational Control (CHOP) line, operational control of convoys was vested in the Commander in Chief of the United States Fleet, through the commander of Task force 24 and east of that line control devolved to the British Commander-in-Chief, Western Approaches based in Liverpool.[2]
Convoys in 1943
After Convoy RA 53 in March, Arctic convoys were suspended for the summer and destroyers on the Arctic run were transferred to Support Groups in the North Atlantic. The 20th Escort Group with eight aged destroyers and Hunt-class destroyers with the 22nd, 23rd and 34th Escort Groups, each of four corvettes were scheduled for refurbishment. Convoy cycles in the North Atlantic were shortened in March to accommodate more traffic, an HX and a SC convoy departing New York each week, that required 12 ocean escort groups were needed, each of three destroyers, a frigate and six corvettes.[3]
The U-boat arm
By the spring of 1943, had expanded to the size advocated by the Befehlshaber der U-Boote (BdU, Commander of U-Boats) Rear-Admiral Karl Dönitz in 1939. In March, 400 U-boats were in service, 47 were close to completion, 245 were under construction and seven U-boats were being converted. Of the 400 boats, 52 (13 per cent) were training submarines, 119 (29.8 per cent) were working up, seven (1.7 per cent) were prototypes and 222 (55.5 per cent) were operational front-line submarines. Eighteen boats were in the Arctic, 19 in the Mediterranean and three in the Black Sea, leaving 182 for operations in the Atlantic. Of the Atlantic boats, on 1 March, 114 (62.6 per cent) were at sea and 68 (37.4 per cent) were in French harbours. Of the U-boats at sea, 44 were in transit (24.2 per cent) and 70 (38.4 per cent) were on patrol in operational areas, 45 in the North Atlantic, 13 in the Central Atlantic, five in the Western Atlantic and seven in the South Atlantic.[4]
Prelude
Convoy HX 231 departed New York on 25 March with 61 merchant ships in an 8 nmi (15 km; 9.2 mi)-wide series of columns but the convoy lost cohesion in fog off the Grand Banks, an underwater plateau to the south-west of Newfoundland. The convoy rendezvoused with Escort Group B7 (Commander Peter Gretton) of the Mid-Ocean Escort Force at the MOMP to the south of Iceland, in the vicinity of 58° North and 35° West. The convoy had been sent northwards into cold and stormy weather. The wind in these high latitudes (closer to the North Pole) comes from the north and west, blowing freezing spray onto ship decks that has to be chipped off with picks and shovels. On the cargo-liner Shillong, the lifeboats along the port side got so icy that the davits bent and the lifeboats were disconnected and tied to the ship, to float free if the ship sank. Life rafts had been swept away along with the main mast that got so brittle in the cold that it snapped. The captain, J. H. Hollow, had to move out of position in the convoy to jettison the wreckage.[5]
Allied order of battle
Merchant ships
| Name | Year | Flag | GRT | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amastra | 1935 | Merchant Navy | 8,031 | |
| Ancylus | 1935 | Merchant Navy | 8,017 | |
| Aruba | 1929 | Netherlands | 3,979 | Arrived with rudder damage |
| MS Asbjörn | 1935 | Merchant Navy | 4,387 | |
| Athelregent | 1930 | Merchant Navy | 8,881 | |
| Athos | 1937 | Norway | 8,267 | |
| Atlantida | 1924 | Honduras | 4,191 | |
| Beaverhill | 1928 | Merchant Navy | 10,041 | |
| Blitar | 1923 | Netherlands | 7,065 | Damaged, U-229 sunk 6 April, U-632, 57°45′N, 27°30′W, 26† 54 surv. |
| British Ardour | 1928 | Merchant Navy | 7,124 | Escort oiler, sunk 5 April, U-706, 58°08′N, 33°04′W 0† 54 surv. |
| British Confidence | 1936 | Merchant Navy | 8,494 | |
| City of Lyons | 1926 | Merchant Navy | 7,063 | |
| Clan Cameron | 1937 | Merchant Navy | 7,243 | |
| Eli Whitney | 1942 | United States | 7,181 | |
| Empire Chief | 1897 | Merchant Navy | 8,040 | Tanker |
| Empire Coleridge | 1942 | Merchant Navy | 9,798 | Tanker equipped with Admiralty Defence Nets |
| Empire Dickens | 1942 | Merchant Navy | 9,819 | Tanker |
| Empire Marvell | 1941) | Merchant Navy | 9,812 | Tanker |
| Erin | 1932 | Merchant Navy | 5,841 | |
| Esso Dover | 1921 | United States | 8,880 | |
| F J Wolfe | 1932 | Merchant Navy | 12,190 | Escort Oiler, turned back with engine trouble |
| Fort Finlay | 1942 | Merchant Navy | 7,134 | |
| Fort Jemseg | 1943 | Merchant Navy | 7,134 | |
| Fort Thompson | 1942 | Merchant Navy | 7,134 | |
| Geo W McKnight | 1933 | Merchant Navy | 12,502 | |
| Georgian | 1920 | United States | 5,825 | |
| Jamaica Planter | 1936 | Merchant Navy | 4,098 | Vice-Convoy Commodore embarked |
| Joel R Poinsett | 1943 | United States | 7,176 | |
| Katy | 1931 | Norway | 6,826 | |
| Kent | 1918 | Merchant Navy | 8,697 | |
| Lady Rodney | 1929 | Merchant Navy | 8,194 | Halifax to St John's, Newfoundland |
| Laurelwood | 1929 | Merchant Navy | 7,347 | |
| Lochmonar | 1924 | Merchant Navy | 9,412 | Returned |
| Manchester Port | 1935 | Merchant Navy | 5,468 | |
| USS Merak | 1932 | United States Navy | 6,982 | Stores and 138 passengers |
| Mobilgas | 1937 | United States | 9,860 | |
| Mosdale | 1939 | Norway | 3,022 | |
| Nassa | 1942 | Merchant Navy | 8,134 | Equipped with Admiralty Defence Nets |
| Noah Webster | 1943 | United States | 7,176 | Turned back |
| Norheim | 1941 | Norway | 9,816 | |
| Norvinn | 1930 | Panama | 6,322 | |
| Ocean Volunteer | 1942 | Merchant Navy | 7,174 | |
| Ørnefjell | 1937 | Norway | 1,334 | Bound for Halifax |
| Pandorian | 1941 | Merchant Navy | 4,159 | |
| Pierre Soule | 1943 | United States | 7,191 | |
| Pleiades | 1939 | United States | 3,600 | |
| Port Sydney | 1914 | Merchant Navy | 9,129 | |
| Raphael Semmes | 1942 | United States | 6,165 | |
| Reinholt | 1939 | Norway | 4,799 | |
| Salland | 1920 | Netherlands | 6,447 | |
| Saluta | 1906 | Merchant Navy | 6,261 | Fuel oil, returned |
| San Adolfo | 1935 | Merchant Navy | 7,365 | |
| San Ambrosio | 1935 | Merchant Navy | 7,410 | |
| Santa Maria | 1942 | United States | 6,507 | |
| Scebeli | 1937 | Norway | 3,025 | Detached and independent, 1 April |
| Shillong | 1939 | Merchant Navy | 5,529 | Damaged, U-635, 57°10′N, 35°30′W, sunk 5 April, U-630, 66† 7 surv. |
| Slemmestad | 1928 | Norway | 4,258 | |
| Sovac | 1937 | Merchant Navy | 6,724 | |
| Stephen C Foster | 1943 | United States | 7,106 | |
| Sunoil | 1927 | United States | 9,005 | Damaged U-563, sunk 5 April, U-530, 58°15′N, 34°14′W, 43† 0 surv |
| Thomas Sumter | 1942 | United States | 7,177 | Romped |
| Tjibadak | 1929 | Netherlands | 7,083 | |
| Torr Head | 1937 | Merchant Navy | 5,021 | |
| Tulsa | 1919 | United States | 5,083 | |
| Tyndareus | 1916 | Merchant Navy | 11,361 | Convoy Commodore, Admiral Sir Charles Ramsey embarked |
| Vaalaren | 1936 | Sweden | 3,403 | Romped 4 April, sunk 5 April, U-229, 58°N, 34°W, 38† 0 surv. |
| Waroonga | 1914 | Merchant Navy | 9,365 | Damaged, U-635, sunk 5 April, U-630, 19† |
| William Mulholland | 1942 | United States | 7,176 | |
| William Whipple | 1942 | United States | 7,181 |
Local escorts
| Name | Flag | Type | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| HMS Buxton | Royal Navy | Clemson-class destroyer | Escort 27–31 March |
| HNoMS Narvik | Royal Norwegian Navy | Hunt-class destroyer | Escort 9–10 April |
| HMCS Chicoutimi | Royal Canadian Navy | Flower-class corvette | Escort 27–31 March |
| HMCS Quesnel | Royal Canadian Navy | Flower-class corvette | Escort 25–31 March |
| HMCS Saskatoon | Royal Canadian Navy | Flower-class corvette | Escort 25–28 March |
| HMCS Kenora | Royal Canadian Navy | Bangor-class minesweeper | Escort 25–28 March |
| HMCS Milltown | Royal Canadian Navy | Bangor-class minesweeper | Escort 27–31 March |
Escort Group B7
| Name | Flag | Type | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| HMS Ripley | Royal Navy | Clemson-class destroyer | Ex-USS Shubrick, under repair at Liverpool |
| HMS Duncan | Royal Navy | D-class destroyer | Under repair at Tobermory |
| HMS Vidette | Royal Navy | V-class destroyer | Escort 31 March – 9 April |
| HMS Tay | Royal Navy | River-class frigate | Escort 31 March – 9 April |
| HMS Alisma | Royal Navy | Flower-class corvette | Escort 31 March – 9 April |
| HMS Loosestrife | Royal Navy | Flower-class corvette | Escort 31 March – 9 April |
| HMS Pink | Royal Navy | Flower-class corvette | Escort 31 March – 9 April |
| HMS Snowflake | Royal Navy | Flower-class corvette | Escort 31 March – 9 April |
| HMS Sunflower | Royal Navy | Flower-class corvette | Under repair at Belfast |
4th Support Group
| Name | Flag | Type | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| HMS Eclipse | Royal Navy | E-class destroyer | Escort 6–8 April |
| HMS Fury | Royal Navy | F-class destroyer | Escort 6–8 April |
| HMS Icarus | Royal Navy | I-class destroyer | Escort 6–8 April |
| HMS Inglefield | Royal Navy | I-class destroyer | Escort 6–8 April |
RAF Coastal Command
| Sqn | Flag | Group | Type | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 86 Squadron | Royal Air Force | 19 Group | Liberator | Very Long Range Anti-submarine warfare aircraft |
| 120 Squadron | Royal Air Force | 15 Group | Liberator | Very Long Range Anti-submarine warfare aircraft |
German order of battle
U-boat wolfpack
| Name | Flag | Class | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| U-168 | Kriegsmarine | Type IXC/40 submarine | |
| U-191 | Kriegsmarine | Type IXC/40 submarine | |
| U-260 | Kriegsmarine | Type VIIC submarine | |
| U-563 | Kriegsmarine | Type VIIC submarine | |
| U-564 | Kriegsmarine | Type VIIC submarine | |
| U-572 | Kriegsmarine | Type VIIC submarine | |
| U-584 | Kriegsmarine | Type VIIC submarine | |
| U-592 | Kriegsmarine | Type VIIC submarine | |
| U-594 | Kriegsmarine | Type VIIC submarine | Damaged by Liberator E, 120 Squadron |
| U-630 | Kriegsmarine | Type VIIC submarine | |
| U-632 | Kriegsmarine | Type VIIC submarine | Sunk by Liberator R, 86 Squadron |
| U-635 | Kriegsmarine | Type VIIC submarine | Sunk by Liberator L, 120 Squadron |
| U-706 | Kriegsmarine | Type VIIC submarine |
Other U-boats
| Name | Flag | Class | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| U-229 | Kriegsmarine | Type VIIC submarine | |
| U-463 | Kriegsmarine | Type XIV submarine | Milchkuh (Milch Cow) |
| U-532 | Kriegsmarine | Type IXC submarine |
References
- ^ a b Rohwer 1977, pp. 27−28.
- ^ Rohwer 1977, p. 28.
- ^ Rohwer 1977, p. 38.
- ^ Rohwer 1977, p. 47.
- ^ Woodman 2004, pp. 645–646.
- ^ Jordan 2006, pp. 11, 88, 100, 103, 105, 107, 109, 127, 132, 133, 134, 145, 150, 152, 154, 160, 166, 170, 174, 178, 180, 187, 197, 214, 274, 286, 302, 310, 312, 315, 324, 329, 331, 371, 383, 396, 418, 419, 422, 423, 450, 472, 482, 483, 489, 511, 520, 521, 550, 564, 573, 575, 586, 595; Mitchell & Sawyer 1990, pp. 33, 145, 147, 386.
- ^ Rohwer 1977, p. 41.
- ^ Rohwer 1977, p. 44.
- ^ a b c Rohwer & Hümmelchen 2005, p. 243.
Bibliography
- Jordan, Roger W. (2006) [1999]. The World's Merchant Fleets 1939: The Particulars and Wartime Fates of 6,000 Ships (2nd ed.). London: Chatham/Lionel Leventhal. ISBN 978-1-86176-293-1.
- Mitchell, W. H.; Sawyer, L. A. (1990). The Empire Ships (2nd ed.). London, New York, Hamburg, Hong Kong: Lloyd's of London Press Ltd. ISBN 1-85044-275-4.
- Rohwer, Jürgen (1977). The Critical Convoy Battles of March 1943: The Battle for HX.229/SC122. Translated by Masters, Derek (Eng. trans. ed.). London: Ian Allan. ISBN 0-7110-0749-7 – via Archive Foundation. Original title "Geleitzugschlachten im März 1943 : Führungsprobleme im Höhepunkt der Schlacht im Atlantik" (Convoy battles in March 1943: Leadership issues at the height of the Battle of the Atlantic) 1975, Motorbuch Verlag, Stuttgart ISBN 978-3-87-943383-4
- Rohwer, Jürgen; Hümmelchen, Gerhard (2005) [1972]. Chronology of the War at Sea, 1939–1945: The Naval History of World War Two (3rd rev. ed.). London: Chatham. ISBN 978-1-86176-257-3.
- Woodman, Richard (2004). The Real Cruel Sea: The Merchant Navy in the Battle of the Atlantic 1939–1943. London: John Murray. ISBN 0-7195-6403-4.
Further reading
- Blair, Clay (2000) [1999]. Hitler's U-Boat War: The Hunted 1942–1945 (pbk. repr. Cassell ed.). London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson. ISBN 0-304-35261-6.
- Gretton, Peter (2021) [1974]. Crisis Convoy: The Story of HX 231 a turning point in the Battle of the Atlantic. Leeds: Sapere Books. ISBN 978-1-80055-276-0.
- Hague, Arnold (2000). The Allied Convoy System 1939–1945. Chatham. ISBN 1-86176-147-3.
- Niestlé, Axel (2014). German U-Boat Losses during World War II: Details of Destruction. Barnsley: Frontline Books. ISBN 978-1-84832-210-3.
External links
- Hague, Arnold. "Convoy HX.231". HX Convoy Series. Don Kindell, Convoyweb.