1999–2000 Port Vale F.C. season

Port Vale
1999–2000 season
ChairmanBill Bell
ManagerBrian Horton
StadiumVale Park
Football League First Division23rd (36 Points)
FA CupThird Round
(knocked out by Leeds United)
League CupFirst Round
(knocked out by Chester City)
Player of the YearTommy Widdrington
Top goalscorerLeague: Tony Rougier (8)
All: Tony Rougier (9)
Highest home attendance10,250 vs. Manchester City, 30 October 1999
Lowest home attendance2,625 vs. Chester City, 24 August 1999
Average home league attendance5,906
Biggest win2–0 (twice) and 3–1 (twice)
Biggest defeat0–3 vs. Ipswich Town, 8 April 2000

The 1999–2000 season was Port Vale's 88th season of football in the English Football League, and sixth successive season in the First Division. Under manager Brian Horton, Vale struggled throughout the campaign and eventually suffered relegation, finishing 23rd, a full 13 points adrift of safety.

In the cups, their efforts were swiftly cut short — they exited the FA Cup in the Third Round, and endured a shock First Round defeat in the League Cup, losing to Fourth Division side Chester City for a second straight season. Despite the lack of incoming transfers, the club sold young players for a total of approximately £1.5 million, a strategic move made amid growing financial woes and the looming threat of bankruptcy. On the field, Tony Rougier emerged as the top scorer, netting eight league goals and nine in all competitions, while stalwart Tony Naylor contributed eight goals over the season. The campaign also marked the transition from the celebrated '90s core — veterans like Martin Foyle, Paul Musselwhite, and Ian Bogie departed, while emerging talents such as Micky Cummins and Mark Goodlad began to feature.

Vale's season ended in disappointment as financial strain and squad turnover contributed to relegation, despite Rougier's goals.

Overview

First Division

The pre-season saw Brian Horton sign Jeff Minton (Brighton & Hove Albion), Tommy Widdrington (Grimsby Town), and Steve Rimmer (Manchester City) on free transfers. He also took Andy Oakes in on loan from Derby County and Matt Glennon from Bolton Wanderers as back-up goalkeepers, and striker Martin Aldridge on loan from Blackpool.

The season started with a goalless draw at Ewood Park with Blackburn Rovers, but soon went downhill with two defeats. Vale then entered inconsistent form, winning three and losing three in a run of six games. On 5 September, Vale beat Grimsby Town by three goals to one, with Bent scoring his first goal for the club.[1] However, just two points from seven October games indicated Vale's future. Also in the month, striker Marcus Bent, signed by John Rudge nine months earlier for £375,000, was sold to Sheffield United for a bargain £300,000 and was later sold on by the "Blades" for a £1.7 million profit. The club set a record on 5 September, when just 3,737 turned up to see a 3–0 win over Grimsby Town – a division record low for a television match.[2] The Vale ended the year in solid form, unbeaten in seven games, despite just two victories (over rivals Crewe Alexandra and against Sheffield United at Bramall Lane).[2] In December, Carl Griffiths was sold back to former club Leyton Orient for £100,000.

In January, Horton signed defender Sagi Burton (Sheffield United) on a free transfer and signed Martin Bullock and Gareth Taylor on one-month loans from Barnsley and Manchester City respectively. Controversially, he also sold promising young defender Anthony Gardner to Tottenham Hotspur for £1 million.[2] On 22 January, Vale won 3–1 at home to Birmingham Citydespite Widdrington being sent off in the opening minute of the match.[3] The next month, David Healy would arrive on loan from Manchester United for the remainder of the season. Also, former international Ville Viljanen became the first Finn to play for the club when he joined from Västra Frölunda IF. In March, Horton made two key signings, bringing two young players that would be with the club for several years to come: Irish midfielder Micky Cummins (Middlesbrough) and goalkeeper Mark Goodlad (Nottingham Forest). He also sold Tony Butler to West Bromwich Albion for £140,000. During this transfer activity, Vale won just once in a sequence of 17 games. A 2–0 win over Portsmouth on 1 April raised hopes of Vale escaping the drop, but Horton's side gained just three points in their final eight games, thus dooming Vale to third-tier football.

They finished in 23rd place with 36 points, a massive 13 points away from the safety of West Bromwich Albion, and only ahead of Swindon Town on goals scored. With just seven victories, they had the fewest wins in the division. Tony Rougier only needed nine goals to become the club's top scorer. The relegation meant that Brian Horton lost his 'proud record' of never being relegated as a player or as a manager.[2]

At the end of the season numerous players were allowed to leave on free transfers: eight-year club veteran goalkeeper Paul Musselwhite (Hull City); five-year club favourite Ian Bogie (Kidderminster Harriers); Wayne Corden (Mansfield Town); Stewart Talbot (Rotherham United);[4] Mark Snijders (AFC '34); Kevin Pilkington (Aberystwyth Town); and Steve Rimmer (Marine). Legendary striker Martin Foyle also retired after nine years as Vale's star striker. Simon Barker also retired at the age of 35. Meanwhile, the club's board increased to five members: Bill Bell (chairman), Andrew Bellfield, Paul Wright, Neil Hughes, and Charles Machin.[5]

Finances

The club's shirt sponsors were Tunstall Assurance.

Cup competitions

In the FA Cup, Vale lost 2–0 to Premier League club Leeds United at Elland Road to exit the competition in the third round. Just 11,912 turned up for the game after the Vale board refused to allow a price reduction.[2]

In the League Cup, for the second successive season, Third Division Chester City knocked the Vale out at the first round. In the 2–1 defeat at the Deva Stadium, both sides finished the game with ten men, and as the return leg was a 4–4 draw, Chester achieved a 6–5 aggregate win.

Results

Football League First Division

League table

Pos Team Pld W D L GF GA GD Pts Qualification or relegation
20 Grimsby Town 46 13 12 21 41 67 −26 51
21 West Bromwich Albion 46 10 19 17 43 60 −17 49
22 Walsall (R) 46 11 13 22 52 77 −25 46 Relegation to the Second Division
23 Port Vale (R) 46 7 15 24 48 69 −21 36
24 Swindon Town (R) 46 8 12 26 38 77 −39 36
Source:
Rules for classification: 1) Points; 2) Goal difference; 3) Goals scored
(R) Relegated

Results by matchday

Round12345678910111213141516171819202122232425262728293031323334353637383940414243444546
GroundAHAHAHHAHAAHHAAHHAHAAHAAHAHHHAHAAHAHAHHAHAAHAH
ResultDLLWLWLLWLDLLDLLWDDWDDDLLDWDLLDLLLDLLWDLDLDLLL
Position12182319201316171517172123212424201920181918202121222223232323232323232323232323232323232323
Points111447771010111111121212151617202122232323242728282829292929303030333434353536363636
Source: Statto[6]
A = Away; H = Home; W = Win; D = Draw; L = Loss

Matches

7 August 1999 1 Blackburn Rovers 0–0 Port Vale Blackburn
Report Stadium: Ewood Park
Attendance: 20,530
Referee: David Laws
14 August 1999 2 Port Vale 1–2 West Bromwich Albion Burslem
Minton 38' (pen.) Report Hughes 14'
Kilbane 55'
Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 7,891
Referee: Eddie Wolstenholme
21 August 1999 3 Birmingham City 4–2 Port Vale Birmingham
Hughes 8', 51'
Furlong 18', 34'
Report Rougier 30'
Naylor 41'
Stadium: St Andrew's
Attendance: 18,089
Referee: Clive Wilkes
28 August 1999 4 Port Vale 1–0 Tranmere Rovers Burslem
Naylor 64' Report Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 4,657
Referee: David Crick
31 August 1999 5 Queens Park Rangers 3–2 Port Vale Shepherd's Bush, West London
Wardley 16', 63'
Kiwomya 77'
Report Minton (75), pen.'
Gardner 79'
Stadium: Loftus Road
Attendance: 9,502
Referee: Steve Bennett
5 September 1999 6 Port Vale 3–1 Grimsby Town Burslem
Bent 21'
Naylor 31'
Foyle 85'
Report Allen 60' Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 3,737
Referee: Mike Dean
11 September 1999 7 Port Vale 0–2 Fulham Burslem
Report Peschisolido 36'
Coleman 56'
Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 6,130
Referee: Mike Jones
18 September 1999 8 Stockport County 1–0 Port Vale Stockport
Nicholson 15' Report Stadium: Edgeley Park
Attendance: 7,632
Referee: Anthony Leake
25 September 1999 9 Port Vale 2–0 Swindon Town Burslem
Carragher 53'
Talia 72' (og.)
Report Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 4,629
Referee: Mike Reed
2 October 1999 10 Manchester City 2–1 Port Vale Manchester
Bishop 30', 36' Report Foyle 63' Stadium: Maine Road
Attendance: 31,608
Referee: Steve Baines
9 October 1999 11 Huddersfield Town 2–2 Port Vale Huddersfield
Stewart 2' (pen.)
Irons 50'
Report Gardner 48'
Foyle 71'
Stadium: Kirklees Stadium
Attendance: 11,885
Referee: Scott Mathieson
16 October 1999 12 Port Vale 0–1 Norwich City Burslem
Report Fleming 82' Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 5,790
Referee: David Elleray
19 October 1999 13 Port Vale 0–2 Nottingham Forest Burslem
19:45 BST Report Bonalair 6'
Wright 44'
Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 5,714
Referee: Barry Knight
23 October 1999 14 Wolverhampton Wanderers 2–2 Port Vale Wolverhampton
Sedgley 47'
Curle 89' (pen.)
Report Walsh 80'
Rougier 84'
Stadium: Molineux Stadium
Attendance: 20,488
Referee: Phil Richards
26 October 1999 15 Swindon Town 2–1 Port Vale Swindon
Onuora 1'
Grazioli 89'
Report Rougier 22' Stadium: County Ground
Attendance: 5,703
Referee: Lee Cable
30 October 1999 16 Port Vale 1–2 Manchester City Burslem
Foyle 40' Report Snijders 72' (og.)
Granville 77'
Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 10,250
Referee: Graham Laws
5 November 1999 17 Port Vale 1–0 Crewe Alexandra Burslem
Rougier 75' Report Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 5,584
Referee: Andrew Hall
12 November 1999 18 Walsall 0–0 Port Vale Walsall
Report Stadium: Bescot Stadium
Attendance: 6,190
Referee: Paul Taylor
20 November 1999 19 Port Vale 2–2 Crystal Palace Burslem
Rougier 20'
Foyle 78'
Report McKenzie 54'
Svensson 88'
Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 5,170
Referee: Roy Pearson
23 November 1999 20 Sheffield United 2–3 Port Vale Sheffield
Sandford 22' Report Eyre 45'
Tankard 71'
Gardner 80'
Stadium: Bramall Lane
Attendance: 8,965
Referee: Trevor Jones
27 November 1999 21 Charlton Athletic 2–2 Port Vale Charlton, London
Mendonca 16', 40' Report Rougier 46'
Foyle 55'
Stadium: The Valley
Attendance: 19,266
Referee: Mick Fletcher
4 December 1999 22 Port Vale 0–0 Blackburn Rovers Burslem
Report Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 6,084
Referee: Paul Rejer
18 December 1999 23 Portsmouth 0–0 Port Vale Portsmouth
Report Stadium: Fratton Park
Attendance: 11,869
Referee: Kevin Lynch
28 December 1999 24 Barnsley 3–1 Port Vale Barnsley
Tinkler 63'
Barnard 67'
Shipperley 87'
Report Minton 71' Stadium: Oakwell
Attendance: 16,855
Referee: Chris Foy
3 January 2000 25 Port Vale 1–2 Ipswich Town Burslem
Naylor 50' Report Holland 43'
Scowcroft 52'
Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 6,908
Referee: Mike Pike
15 January 2000 26 West Bromwich Albion 0–0 Port Vale West Bromwich
Report Stadium: The Hawthorns
Attendance: 10,831
Referee: Rob Styles
22 January 2000 27 Port Vale 3–1 Birmingham City Burslem
Naylor 14'
Widdrington 86' (pen.)
Rougier 90'
Report Hughes 48' Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 7,702
Referee: George Cain
5 February 2000 28 Port Vale 1–1 Queens Park Rangers Burslem
Bullock 28' Report Wardley 37' Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 5,493
Referee: John Kirkby
8 February 2000 29 Port Vale 0–1 Bolton Wanderers Burslem
Report Guðjohnsen 77' Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 5,092
Referee: Terry Heilbron
12 February 2000 30 Grimsby Town 2–0 Port Vale Cleethorpes
Clare 19'
Allen 27'
Report Stadium: Blundell Park
Attendance: 6,265
Referee: Phil Richards
26 February 2000 31 Port Vale 1–1 Stockport County Burslem
Widdrington 45' Report Wilbraham 9' Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 5,663
Referee: Phil Joslin
4 March 2000 32 Fulham 3–1 Port Vale Fulham, West London
Clark 15', 52'
Melville 29'
Report Healy 74' Stadium: Craven Cottage
Attendance: 10,418
Referee: Guy Stretton
7 March 2000 33 Crewe Alexandra 2–1 Port Vale Crewe
Cramb
Lunt
Report Viljanen Stadium: Gresty Road
Attendance: 8,044
Referee: Alan Butler
11 March 2000 34 Port Vale 2–3 Sheffield United Burslem
Healy 45'
Rougier 90'
Report Bent 23'
Woodhouse 47'
D'Jaffo 49'
Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 5,484
Referee: Mark Cowburn
18 March 2000 35 Crystal Palace 1–1 Port Vale Selhurst, Croydon
Rougier 64' (og.) Report Widdrington 73' (pen.) Stadium: Selhurst Park
Attendance: 18,954
Referee: Matt Messias
21 March 2000 36 Port Vale 1–2 Walsall Burslem
Cummins 59' Report Matías 12'
Fenton 45'
Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 5,737
Referee: Graham Frankland
25 March 2000 37 Bolton Wanderers 2–1 Port Vale Bolton
Guðjohnsen 16'
Johnston 42'
Report Viljanen 53' Stadium: Reebok Stadium
Attendance: 12,292
Referee: David Laws
1 April 2000 38 Port Vale 2–0 Portsmouth Burslem
Viljanen 15'
Widdrington 43' (pen.)
Report Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 5,426
Referee: Paul Rejer
4 April 2000 39 Port Vale 2–2 Charlton Athletic Burslem
Viljanen 39'
Burton 68'
Report Rufus 63'
Hunt 74'
Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 4,513
Referee: Bill Jordan
8 April 2000 40 Ipswich Town 3–0 Port Vale Ipswich
Scowcroft 12'
Johnson 39'
Holland 83'
Report Stadium: Portman Road
Attendance: 19,663
Referee: Steve Baines
15 April 2000 41 Port Vale 2–2 Barnsley Burslem
Burton 90'
Widdrington 90' (pen.)
Report Hignett 43'
Curtis 66'
Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 5,918
Referee: Paul Taylor
18 April 2000 42 Tranmere Rovers 2–1 Port Vale Prenton
Kelly 60', 89' Report Healy 41' Stadium: Prenton Park
Attendance: 5,602
Referee: Paul Alcock
22 April 2000 43 Norwich City 0–0 Port Vale Norwich
Report Stadium: Carrow Road
Attendance: 15,526
Referee: Mark Halsey
24 April 2000 44 Port Vale 1–2 Huddersfield Town Burslem
Naylor 38' Report Vincent 8'
Irons 54' (pen.)
Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 5,828
Referee: Trevor Jones
29 April 2000 45 Nottingham Forest 2–0 Port Vale Nottingham
19:45 BST John 11'
Prutton 34'
Report Stadium: City Ground
Attendance: 15,534
Referee: Mike Riley
7 May 2000 46 Port Vale 0–1 Wolverhampton Wanderers Burslem
Report Robinson 85' Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 8,525
Referee: Clive Wilkes

FA Cup

12 December 1999 R3 Leeds United 2–0 Port Vale Beeston, Leeds
Bakke 61', 68' Report Stadium: Elland Road
Attendance: 11,912
Referee: Steve Dunn

League Cup

10 August 1999 R1 1st Leg Chester City 2–1 Port Vale Chester
Richardson 7'
Beckett 72' (pen.)
Report Rougier 15' Stadium: Deva Stadium
Attendance: 2,102
Referee: Trevor Jones
24 August 1999 R1 2nd Leg Port Vale 4–4
(5–6 agg.)
Chester City Burslem
Naylor 35', 64'
Minton 45' (pen.)
Griffiths 84'
Report Beckett 5', 13' (pen.)
Shelton 71'
Jones 77'
Stadium: Vale Park
Attendance: 2,625

Player statistics

Appearances and goals

Key to positions: GK – Goalkeeper; DF – Defender; MF – Midfielder; FW – Forward
Pos. # Name Football League FA Cup League Cup Total
Apps Goals Apps Goals Apps Goals Apps Goals
GK 1 Paul Musselwhite 30 0 1 0 1 0 32 0
DF 2 Michael Walsh 12 1 0 0 2 0 14 1
DF 3 Allen Tankard 35 1 1 0 1 0 37 1
MF 4 Dave Brammer 29 0 0 0 2 0 31 0
FW 6 Ville Viljanen 14 4 0 0 0 0 14 4
DF 7 Alex Smith 13 0 0 0 2 0 15 0
MF 8 Micky Cummins 12 1 0 0 0 0 12 1
DF 9 Sagi Burton 20 2 0 0 0 0 22 2
MF 10 Jeff Minton 23 3 1 0 2 1 26 4
MF 11 Tommy Widdrington 38 5 1 0 0 0 39 5
FW 12 Tony Naylor 36 6 1 0 2 2 39 8
GK 13 Kevin Pilkington 15 0 0 0 1 0 16 0
MF 14 Richard Eyre 30 1 1 0 2 0 33 1
FW 15 Martin Foyle 22 6 1 0 1 0 24 6
MF 16 Wayne Corden 2 0 0 0 0 0 2 0
MF 17 Tony Rougier 38 8 1 0 2 1 41 9
MF 18 George O'Callaghan 11 0 0 0 0 0 11 0
DF 19 Matt Carragher 37 1 0 0 2 0 39 1
DF 20 Steve Rimmer 2 0 0 0 0 0 2 0
DF 21 Liam Burns 24 0 1 0 0 0 25 0
MF 22 Neil Brisco 13 0 1 0 0 0 14 0
MF 23 Stewart Talbot 6 0 0 0 0 0 6 0
FW 24 David Healy 16 3 0 0 0 0 16 3
MF 25 Ian Bogie 9 0 0 0 0 0 9 0
GK 26 Mark Goodlad 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0
DF 27 Mark Snijders 21 0 1 0 0 0 22 0
DF 28 Paul Donnelly 4 0 0 0 0 0 4 0
MF 29 Stewart Clitheroe 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
FW 30 Anthony Tarr 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MF 31 Paul Taylor 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
GK 32 Chris Gowen 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Players that left the club mid-season:
DF 5 Tony Butler 15 0 0 0 0 0 15 0
DF 6 Anthony Gardner 26 3 1 0 2 0 29 3
FW 8 Marcus Bent 8 1 0 0 1 0 9 1
MF 8 Martin Bullock 6 1 0 0 0 0 6 1
FW 9 Carl Griffiths 5 0 0 0 2 1 7 1
MF 24 Simon Barker 5 0 0 0 1 0 6 0
DF 24 Gareth Taylor 4 0 0 0 0 0 4 0
GK 26 Andy Oakes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
GK 26 Matt Glennon 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
FW 33 Martin Aldridge 3 0 0 0 0 0 3 0

Top scorers

Place Position Nation Number Name First Division FA Cup League Cup Total
1 MF  Trinidad 17 Tony Rougier 8 0 1 9
2 FW  England 12 Tony Naylor 6 0 2 8
3 FW  England 15 Martin Foyle 6 0 0 6
4 MF  England 11 Tommy Widdrington 5 0 0 5
FW  Finland 6 Ville Viljanen 4 0 0 4
6 MF  England 10 Jeff Minton 3 0 1 4
7 DF  England} 6 Anthony Gardner 3 0 0 3
FW  Northern Ireland 24 David Healy 3 0 0 3
9 DF  Saint Kitts 9 Sagi Burton 2 0 0 2
10 MF  England 14 Richard Eyre 1 0 0 1
DF  England 3 Allen Tankard 1 0 0 1
DF  England 19 Matt Carragher 1 0 0 1
FW  England 8 Marcus Bent 1 0 0 1
DF  England 2 Michael Walsh 1 0 0 1
MF  England 8 Martin Bullock 1 0 0 1
MF  Ireland 8 Micky Cummins 1 0 0 1
FW  England 9 Carl Griffiths 0 0 1 1
Own goals 1 0 0 0
TOTALS 48 0 5 53

Transfers

Transfers in

Date from Position Nationality Name From Fee Ref.
June 1999 MF Jeff Minton Brighton & Hove Albion Free transfer [7]
June 1999 DF Steve Rimmer Manchester City Free transfer [7]
June 1999 MF Tommy Widdrington Grimsby Town Free transfer [7]
January 2000 DF Sagi Burton Sheffield United Free transfer [7]
February 2000 FW Ville Viljanen Västra Frölunda IF Free transfer [7]
March 2000 MF Micky Cummins Middlesbrough Free transfer [7]
March 2000 GK Mark Goodlad Nottingham Forest Free transfer [7]

Transfers out

Date from Position Nationality Name To Fee Ref.
October 1999 FW Marcus Bent Sheffield United £375,000 [7]
December 1999 FW Carl Griffiths Leyton Orient £100,000 [7]
January 2000 DF Anthony Gardner Tottenham Hotspur £1 million [7]
March 2000 DF Tony Butler West Bromwich Albion £140,000 [7]
April 2000 MF Ian Bogie Kidderminster Harriers Free transfer [7]
May 2000 MF Simon Barker Retired [7]
May 2000 DF Steve Rimmer Marine Released [7]
July 2000 MF Stewart Talbot Rotherham United Free transfer [7]
Summer 2000 MF Wayne Corden Mansfield Town Free transfer [7]
Summer 2000 FW Martin Foyle Retired [7]
Summer 2000 GK Paul Musselwhite Sheffield Wednesday Free transfer [7]
Summer 2000 GK Kevin Pilkington Aberystwyth Town Free transfer [7]
Summer 2000 DF Mark Snijders AFC '34 Released [7]
11 August 2000 MF Tony Rougier Reading £325,000 [7]

Loans in

Date from Position Nationality Name From Date to Ref.
20 August 1999 GK Andy Oakes Derby County 10 September 1999 [7]
10 September 1999 GK Matt Glennon Bolton Wanderers 20 October 1999 [7]
27 September 1999 FW Martin Aldridge Blackpool 27 October 1999 [7]
11 January 2000 MF Martin Bullock Barnsley 28 February 2000 [7]
19 January 2000 FW Gareth Taylor Manchester City 16 February 2000 [7]
19 February 2000 MF David Healy Manchester United 8 May 2000 [7]

References

Specific
  1. ^ Baggaley, Mike (5 September 2024). "Options and injury news". Valiant's Substack. Retrieved 6 September 2024.
  2. ^ a b c d e "Vale slide into Division Two". BBC Sport. 28 June 2000. Retrieved 18 January 2011.
  3. ^ Baggaley, Mike (27 August 2025). "Super Vale stun Birmingham". Valiant's Substack. Retrieved 27 August 2025.
  4. ^ "Millers snap up Talbot". BBC Sport. 12 July 2000. Retrieved 18 January 2011.
  5. ^ "Board change at Vale". BBC Sport. 10 July 2000. Retrieved 18 January 2011.
  6. ^ Port Vale 1999–2000 : Results & Fixtures. Statto Organisation. Retrieved 28 April 2012.
  7. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z aa "Port Vale FC Club Details | Transfers | Soccer Base". www.soccerbase.com. Retrieved 7 October 2016.
General