1920 Edmonton municipal election

The 1920 municipal election was held December 13, 1920, to elect a mayor and six aldermen to sit on Edmonton City Council and three trustees to sit on the public school board. J Cormack, Joseph Gariépy and J J Murray were acclaimed to two-year terms on the separate school board. In a plebiscite held at the same time, Edmontonians repeated their previous year's rejection of a proposal to pay aldermen. Ratepayers also voted down the various money bylaws that were up for discussion.[1]

There were ten aldermen on city council, but four of the positions were already filled: Percy Abbott, John Bowen, James East and Rice Sheppard were all elected to two-year terms in 1919 and were still in office. J. A. Kinney had also been elected to a two-year term in 1919, but had resigned. Accordingly, Samuel McCoppen, who came in in sixth place, was elected to a one-year term.

Five candidates of a new party, the business-oriented Citizens Progressive League AKA the Citizens Committee or Citizens ticket, were elected to most of the open seats. McCoppen was the sole Labour Party candidate to be elected.[2] A third party, the Independent Labor Party, ran two candidates but did not elect anyone.[3]

There were seven trustees on the public school board, but four of the positions were already filled: Samuel Barnes, J. W. H. Williams, J A McPherson, and Frank Scott had all been elected to two-year terms in 1919 and were still in office. The same was true on the separate board, where Joseph Henri Picard, Paul Jenvrin, Thomas Magee, and Thomas Malone were continuing.

Voter turnout

There were 14,710 ballots cast out of 26,903 eligible voters, for a voter turnout of 54.6%.

Results

Mayor

Party Candidate Votes %
  Citizens' Progressive League David Duggan 7,537 51.78%
  Labour Joseph Clarke 6,974 47.90%
  Independent Albert Stimmel 47 0.32%

Aldermen

Block voting was used - each voter cast up to six votes.

Party Candidate Votes
  Citizens' Progressive League Joseph Adair 7,023
  Citizens' Progressive League Andrew McLennan 6,996
  Citizens' Progressive League Valentine Richards
(South Side)
6,385
  Citizens' Progressive League James Collisson 6,280
  Citizens' Progressive League William Campbell McArthur 5,679
  Dominion Labour Party Samuel McCoppen 5,478
  Dominion Labour Party A. Boileau 5,133
  Citizens' Progressive League W. H. Speer 5,111
  Dominion Labour Party Alfred Farmilo 4,638
  Dominion Labour Party Daniel Kennedy Knott 4,625
  Dominion Labour Party J. J. Murray 4,574
  Dominion Labour Party G. Latham 4,312
  Independent John McKenzie 3,040
  Independent Labor Party George L. Ritchie 1,610
  Independent Labor Party Joseph White[4] 957
  Independent Hyman King[5] 760

Public school trustees

Block voting was used - each voter cast up to three votes.

Party Candidate Votes
  Citizens' Progressive League Mrs. E. T. (Thryza) Bishop 6,988
  Citizens' Progressive League William Hardy Alexander 6,711
  Citizens' Progressive League William Rea 6,667
  Labour J. W. B. Williams 5,599
  Labour Frank Crang 5,444
  Labour J. Heron 4,137

Separate (Catholic) school trustees

Party Candidate Votes
  Independent J. Cormack acclaimed
  Independent Joseph Gariépy acclaimed
  Independent J. J. Murray
(South Side)
acclaimed

Plebiscite

Should Aldermen be paid?
Votes %
Yes 4,234 32.46%
No 8,811 67.54%

Ratepayers voted down the various money bylaws that were up for discussion.[6]

References

  1. ^ "D.M. Duggan elected mayor... in Monday's election", Edmonton Bulletin, December 15, 1920, p. 1 https://archive.org/details/EDI_1920121401/mode/2up?view=theater accessed September 5, 2025
  2. ^ "Civic Elections Monday Dec. 13", Edmonton Bulletin, December 14, 1920, p. 1
  3. ^ "D.M. Duggan elected mayor", Edmonton Bulletin, December 14, 1920, p. 1
  4. ^ Edmonton Bulletin, Dec. 7, 1921, p.1
  5. ^ Edmonton Bulletin, Dec. 7, 1921, p.1
  6. ^ "D.M. Duggan elected mayor... in Monday's election", Edmonton Bulletin, December 15, 1920, p. 1 https://archive.org/details/EDI_1920121401/mode/2up?view=theater accessed September 5, 2025